Luca Biasco

Multilineage hematopoietic reconstitution without clonal selection in ADA-SCID patients treated with stem cell gene therapy

Gene transfer into HSCs is an effective treatment for SCID, although potentially limited by the risk of insertional mutagenesis. We performed a genome-wide analysis of retroviral vector integrations in genetically corrected HSCs and their multilineage progeny before and up to 47 months after transplantation into 5 patients with adenosine deaminase-deficient SCID. Gene-dense regions, promoters, and transcriptionally active genes were preferred retroviral integrations sites (RISs) both in preinfusion transduced CD34(+) cells and in vivo after gene therapy. The occurrence of insertion sites proximal to protooncogenes or genes controlling cell growth and self renewal, including LMO2, was not associated with clonal selection or expansion in vivo. Clonal analysis of long-term repopulating cell progeny in vivo revealed highly polyclonal T cell populations and shared RISs among multiple lineages, demonstrating the engraftment of multipotent HSCs. These data have important implications for the biology of retroviral vectors, the dynamics of genetically modified HSCs, and the safety of gene therapy.

Comprehensive genomic access to vector integration in clinical gene therapy.

Retroviral vectors have induced subtle clonal skewing in many gene therapy patients and severe clonal proliferation and leukemia in some of them, emphasizing the need for comprehensive integration site analyses to assess the biosafety and genomic pharmacokinetics of vectors and clonal fate of gene-modified cells in vivo. Integration site analyses such as linear amplification–mediated PCR (LAM-PCR) require a restriction digest generating unevenly small fragments of the genome. Here we show that each restriction motif allows for identification of only a fraction of all genomic integrants, hampering the understanding and prediction of biological consequences after vector insertion. We developed a model to define genomic access to the viral integration site that provides optimal restriction motif combinations and minimizes the percentage of nonaccessible insertion loci. We introduce a new nonrestrictive LAM-PCR approach that has superior capabilities for comprehensive unbiased integration site retrieval in preclinical and clinical samples independent of restriction motifs and amplification inefficiency.

Retroviral Integrations in Gene Therapy Trials

γ-Retroviral and lentiviral vectors allow the permanent integration of a therapeutic transgene in target cells and have provided in the last decade a delivery platform for several successful gene therapy (GT) clinical approaches. However, the occurrence of adverse events due to insertional mutagenesis in GT treated patients poses a strong challenge to the scientific community to identify the mechanisms at the basis of vector-driven genotoxicity. Along the last decade, the study of retroviral integration sites became a fundamental tool to monitor vector–host interaction in patients overtime. This review is aimed at critically revising the data derived from insertional profiling, with a particular focus on the evidences collected from GT clinical trials. We discuss the controversies and open issues associated to the interpretation of integration site analysis during patients follow up, with an update on the latest results derived from the use of high-throughput technologies. Finally, we provide a perspective on the future technical development and on the application of these studies to address broader biological questions, from basic virology to human hematopoiesis.

Integration profile of retroviral vector in gene therapy treated patients is cell-specific according to gene expression and chromatin conformation of target cell

The analysis of genomic distribution of retroviral vectors is a powerful tool to monitor ‘vector‐on‐host’ effects in gene therapy (GT) trials but also provides crucial information about ‘host‐on‐vector’ influences based on the target cell genetic and epigenetic state. We had the unique occasion to compare the insertional profile of the same therapeutic moloney murine leukemia virus (MLV) vector in the context of the adenosine deaminase‐severe combined immunodeficiency (ADA‐SCID) genetic background in two GT trials based on infusions of transduced mature lymphocytes (peripheral blood lymphocytes, PBL) or a single infusion of haematopoietic stem/progenitor cells (HSC). We found that vector insertions are cell‐specific according to the differential expression profile of target cells, favouring, in PBL‐GT, genes involved in immune system and T‐cell functions/pathways as well as T‐cell DNase hypersensitive sites, differently from HSC‐GT. Chromatin conformations and histone modifications influenced integration preferences but we discovered that only H3K27me3 was cell‐specifically disfavoured, thus representing a key epigenetic determinant of cell‐type dependent insertion distribution. Our study shows that MLV vector insertional profile is cell‐specific according to the genetic/chromatin state of the target cell both in vitro and in vivo in patients several years after GT.

In vivo tracking of T cells in humans unveils decade-long survival and activity of genetically modified T memory stem cells

Genetically engineered T memory stem cells preserve differentiation activity for decades after patient infusion. Sealing T cell fate Clinical trials are a relatively untapped source of experimental data that can be leveraged to explore both basic and pathological biology in humans. Now, Biasco et al. take advantage of two different gene therapy trials for inherited immunodeficiency to track in the long term T cell fate in humans. They find that the recently described T memory stem cells (TSCM) are able to persist and preserve their precursor potential in human recipients for up to 12 years after genetic correction and infusion into patients. The safety and long-term survival of these cells not only strengthen our knowledge of human immunology but also support the use of TSCM cells for adoptive immunotherapy. A definitive understanding of survival and differentiation potential in humans of T cell subpopulations is of paramount importance for the development of effective T cell therapies. In particular, uncovering the dynamics in vivo in humans of the recently described T memory stem cells (TSCM) would be crucial for therapeutic approaches that aim at taking advantage of a stable cellular vehicle with precursor potential. We exploited data derived from two gene therapy clinical trials for an inherited immunodeficiency, using either retrovirally engineered hematopoietic stem cells or mature lymphocytes to trace individual T cell clones directly in vivo in humans. We compared healthy donors and bone marrow–transplanted patients, studied long-term in vivo T cell composition under different clinical conditions, and specifically examined TSCM contribution according to age, conditioning regimen, disease background, cell source, long-term reconstitution, and ex vivo gene correction processing. High-throughput sequencing of retroviral vector integration sites (ISs) allowed tracing the fate of more than 1700 individual T cell clones in gene therapy patients after infusion of gene-corrected hematopoietic stem cells or mature lymphocytes. We shed light on long-term in vivo clonal relationships among different T cell subtypes, and we unveiled that TSCM are able to persist and to preserve their precursor potential in humans for up to 12 years after infusion of gene-corrected lymphocytes. Overall, this work provides high-resolution tracking of T cell fate and activity and validates, in humans, the safe and functional decade-long survival of engineered TSCM, paving the way for their future application in clinical settings.

Tracking genetically engineered lymphocytes long-term reveals the dynamics of T cell immunological memory

Antigen exposure and differentiation phenotype influence long-term persistence of memory T cells after hematopoietic stem cell transplant. Committing T cells to memory Adoptive cell transfer is an increasingly successful therapy for a variety of diseases; however, little is known about what regulates the survival of these cells in humans. Now, Oliveira et al. leverage patients who have received genetically modified hematopoietic stem cells to track T cells over time. They found labeled effector memory, central memory, and stem memory T cells 2 to 14 years after infusion in all patients. Antigen recognition was critical in driving persistence and expansion. The clones that survived long-term appeared to initiate preferentially from central and stem cell memory T cell populations. These data suggest that the original phenotype of infused cells may influence long-term persistence of adoptively transferred cells. Long-lasting immune protection from pathogens and cancer requires the generation of memory T cells able to survive long-term. To unravel the immunological requirements for long-term persistence of human memory T cells, we characterized and traced, over several years, T lymphocytes genetically modified to express the thymidine kinase (TK) suicide gene that were infused in 10 patients after haploidentical hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT). At 2 to 14 years after infusion and in the presence of a broad and resting immune system, we could still detect effectors/effector memory (TEM/EFF), central memory (TCM), and stem memory (TSCM) TK+ cells, circulating at low but stable levels in all patients. Longitudinal analysis of cytomegalovirus (CMV)– and Flu-specific TK+ cells indicated that antigen recognition was dominant in driving in vivo expansion and persistence at detectable levels. The amount of infused TSCM cells positively correlated with early expansion and with the absolute counts of long-term persisting gene-marked cells. By combining T cell sorting with sequencing of integration (IS), TCRα and TCRβ clonal markers, we showed that T cells retrieved long-term were enriched in clones originally shared in different memory T cell subsets, whereas dominant long-term clonotypes appeared to preferentially originate from infused TSCM and TCM clones. Together, these results indicate that long-term persistence of gene-modified memory T cells after haploidentical HSCT is influenced by antigen exposure and by the original phenotype of infused cells. Cancer adoptive immunotherapy might thus benefit from cellular products enriched in lymphocytes with an early-differentiated phenotype.

Safety of Gene Therapy: New Insights to a Puzzling Case

Over the last few years, the transfer of therapeutic genes via gammaretro- or lentiviral vector systems has proven its virtue as an alternative treatment for a series of genetic disorders. The number of approved phase I/II clinical trials, especially for rare diseases, is steadily increasing, but the overall hurdles to become a broadly acceptable therapy remain numerous. The efforts by clinicians and basic scientists have tremendously improved the knowledge available about feasibility and biosafety of gene therapy. Nonetheless, despite the generation of a plethora of clinical and preclinical safety data, we still lack sufficiently powerful assays to predictively assess the exact levels of toxicity that might be observed in any given clinical gene therapy. Insertional mutagenesis is one of the major concerns when using integrating vectors for permanent cell modification, and the occurrence of adverse events related to genotoxicity, in early gene therapy trials, has refrained the field of gene therapy from emerging further. In this review, we provided a comprehensive overview on the basic principles and potential co-factors concurring in the generation of adverse events reported in gene therapy clinical trials using integrating vectors. Additionally, we summarized the available systems to assess genotoxicity at the preclinical level and we shed light on the issues affecting the predictive value of these assays when translating their results into the clinical arena. In the last section of the review we briefly touched on the future trends and how they could increase the safety of gene therapy employing integrating vector technology to take it to the next level.

Shedding of clinical-grade lentiviral vectors is not detected in a gene therapy setting.

Gene therapy using viral vectors that stably integrate into ex vivo cultured cells holds great promises for the treatment of monogenic diseases as well as cancer. However, carry-over of infectious vector particles has been described to occur upon ex vivo transduction of target cells. This, in turn, may lead to inadvertent spreading of viral particles to off-target cells in vivo, raising concerns for potential adverse effects, such as toxicity of ectopic transgene expression, immunogenicity from in vivo transduced antigen-presenting cells and, possibly, gene transfer to germline cells. Here, we have investigated factors influencing the extent of lentiviral vector (LV) shedding upon ex vivo transduction of human hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells. Our results indicate that, although vector carry-over is detectable when using laboratory-grade vector stocks, the use of clinical-grade vector stocks strongly decreases the extent of inadvertent transduction of secondary targets, likely because of the higher degree of purification. These data provide supportive evidence for the safe use of the LV platform in clinical settings.

Preclinical Efficacy and Safety Evaluation of Hematopoietic Stem Cell Gene Therapy in a Mouse Model of MNGIE

Mitochondrial neurogastrointestinal encephalomyopathy (MNGIE) is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by thymidine phosphorylase (TP) deficiency resulting in systemic accumulation of thymidine (d-Thd) and deoxyuridine (d-Urd) and characterized by early-onset neurological and gastrointestinal symptoms. Long-term effective and safe treatment is not available. Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation may improve clinical manifestations but carries disease and transplant-related risks. In this study, lentiviral vector-based hematopoietic stem cell gene therapy (HSCGT) was performed in Tymp−/−Upp1−/− mice with the human phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) promoter driving TYMP. Supranormal blood TP activity reduced intestinal nucleoside levels significantly at low vector copy number (median, 1.3; range, 0.2–3.6). Furthermore, we covered two major issues not addressed before. First, we demonstrate aberrant morphology of brain astrocytes in areas of spongy degeneration, which was reversed by HSCGT. Second, long-term follow-up and vector integration site analysis were performed to assess safety of the therapeutic LV vectors in depth. This report confirms and supplements previous work on the efficacy of HSCGT in reducing the toxic metabolites in Tymp−/−Upp1−/− mice, using a clinically applicable gene transfer vector and a highly efficient gene transfer method, and importantly demonstrates phenotypic correction with a favorable risk profile, warranting further development toward clinical implementation.

531. Computational Pipeline for the Identification of Integration Sites and Novel Method for the Quantification of Clone Sizes in Clonal Tracking Studies

Gene-corrected cells in Gene Therapy (GT) treated patients can be tracked in vivo by means of vector integration site (IS) analysis, since each engineered clone becomes univocally and stably marked by an individual IS. As the proper IS identification and quantification is crucial to accurately perform clonal tracking studies, we designed a customizable and tailored pipeline to analyze LAM-PCR amplicons sequenced by Illumina MiSeq/HiSeq technology. The sequencing data are initially processed through a series of quality filters and cleaned from vector and Linker Cassette (LC) sequences with customizable settings. Demultiplexing is then performed according to the recognition of specific barcodes combination used upon library preparation and the sequences are aligned to the reference genome. Importantly, the human genome assembly Hg19 is composed of 93 contigs, among which the mitochondrial genome, unlocalized and unplaced contigs and some alternative haplotypes of chr6. While previous approaches aligned IS sequences only to the standard 24 human chromosomes, using the whole assembled genome allowed improving alignment accuracy and concomitantly increased the amount of detectable ISs. To date, we have processed 28 independent human sample sets retrieving 260,994 ISs from 189,270,566 sequencing reads. Although, sequencing read counts at each IS have been widely used to estimate the relative IS abundance, this method carries inherent accuracy constraints due to the rounds of exponential amplification required by LAM-PCR that might generate unbalances on the original clonal representation. More recently, a method based on genomic sonication has been proposed exploiting shear site counts to tag the number of original fragments belonging to each IS before PCR amplification. However, the number of cells composing a given clone could far exceed the number of fragments of different lengths that can be generated upon fragmentation in proximity of that given IS. This would rapidly saturate the available diversity of shear sites and progressively generate more and more same-site shearing on independent genomes. In order to overcome the described biases and reliably quantify ISs, we designed and tested a new LC encoding random barcodes. The new LC is composed of a known sequence of 29nt used as binding site for the primers upon amplification steps, a 6nt-random barcode, a fixed-anchor sequence of 6nt, a second 6nt-random barcode and a final known sequence of 22nt containing sticky ends for the three main restriction enzymes in use (MluI, HpyCH4IV and AciI). This peculiar design allowed increasing the accuracy of clonal diversity estimation since the fixed-anchor sequence acts as a control for sequencing reliability in the barcode area. The theoretical number of different available barcodes per clone (412=16,777,216) far exceeds the requirements for not saturating the original diversity of the analyzed sample (on average composed by around 50.000 cells). We validated this novel approach by performing assays on serial dilutions of individual clones carrying known ISs. The precision rate obtained was averagely around 99.3%, while the worst error rate reaches at most the 1.86%, confirming the reliability of IS quantification. We successfully applied the barcoded-LC system to the analysis of clinical samples from a Wiskott Aldrich Syndrome GT patient, collecting to date 50,215 barcoded ISs from 94,052,785 sequencing reads.