Patrick J. Macdonald

APOBEC3 Multimerization Correlates with HIV-1 Packaging and Restriction Activity in Living Cells

APOBEC3G belongs to a family of DNA cytosine deaminases that are involved in the restriction of a broad number of retroviruses including human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1). Prior studies have identified two distinct mechanistic steps in Vif-deficient HIV-1 restriction: packaging into virions and deaminating viral cDNA. APOBEC3A, for example, although highly active, is not packaged and is therefore not restrictive. APOBEC3G, on the other hand, although having weaker enzymatic activity, is packaged into virions and is strongly restrictive. Although a number of studies have described the propensity for APOBEC3 oligomerization, its relevance to HIV-1 restriction remains unclear. Here, we address this problem by examining APOBEC3 oligomerization in living cells using molecular brightness analysis. We find that APOBEC3G forms high-order multimers as a function of protein concentration. In contrast, APOBEC3A, APOBEC3C and APOBEC2 are monomers at all tested concentrations. Among other members of the APOBEC3 family, we show that the multimerization propensities of APOBEC3B, APOBEC3D, APOBEC3F and APOBEC3H (haplotype II) bear more resemblance to APOBEC3G than to APOBEC3A/3C/2. Prior studies have shown that all of these multimerizing APOBEC3 proteins, but not the monomeric family members, have the capacity to package into HIV-1 particles and restrict viral infectivity. This correlation between oligomerization and restriction is further evidenced by two different APOBEC3G mutants, which are each compromised for multimerization, packaging and HIV-1 restriction. Overall, our results imply that multimerization of APOBEC3 proteins may be related to the packaging mechanism and ultimately to virus restriction.

Observing protein interactions and their stoichiometry in living cells by brightness analysis of fluorescence fluctuation experiments.

A single fluorescently labeled protein generates a short burst of light whenever it passes through a tiny observation volume created within a biological cell. The average amplitude of the burst is related to the stoichiometry of the fluorescently labeled protein complex. Fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy quantifies the burst amplitude by introducing the brightness parameter. Brightness provides a spectroscopic marker for observing protein interactions and their stoichiometry directly inside cells. Not all fluorescent proteins are suitable for brightness experiments. Here we discuss how brightness properties of the fluorophore influence brightness measurements and how to identify a well-behaved fluorescent protein. Protein interactions and stoichiometry are determined from a brightness titration. Experimental details of brightness titration measurements are described together with the necessary calibration and control experiments.

Characterization of Cytoplasmic Gag-Gag Interactions by Dual-Color Z-Scan Fluorescence Fluctuation Spectroscopy

Fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (FFS) quantifies the interactions of fluorescently-labeled proteins inside living cells by brightness analysis. However, the study of cytoplasmic proteins that interact with the plasma membrane is challenging with FFS. If the cytoplasmic section is thinner than the axial size of the observation volume, cytoplasmic and membrane-bound proteins are coexcited, which leads to brightness artifacts. This brightness bias, if not recognized, leads to erroneous interpretation of the data. We have overcome this challenge by introducing dual-color z-scan FFS and the addition of a distinctly colored reference protein. Here, we apply this technique to study the cytoplasmic interactions of the Gag proteins from human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) and human T-lymphotropic virus type 1 (HTLV-1). The Gag protein plays a crucial role in the assembly of retroviruses and is found in both membrane and cytoplasm. Dual-color z-scans demonstrate that brightness artifacts are caused by a dim nonpunctate membrane-bound fraction of Gag. We perform an unbiased brightness characterization of cytoplasmic Gag by avoiding the membrane-bound fraction and reveal previously unknown differences in the behavior of the two retroviral Gag species. HIV-1 Gag exhibits concentration-dependent oligomerization in the cytoplasm, whereas HTLV-1 Gag lacks significant cytoplasmic Gag-Gag interactions.

Brightness Analysis by Z-Scan Fluorescence Fluctuation Spectroscopy for the Study of Protein Interactions within Living Cells

Fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (FFS) quantifies interactions of fluorescently labeled proteins inside living cells by brightness analysis. Conventional FFS implicitly requires that the sample thickness exceeds the size of the observation volume. This condition is not always fulfilled when measuring cells. Cytoplasmic sections, especially, can be thinner than the axial size of the observation volume. The finite sample thickness introduces a brightness bias which, if not recognized, leads to an erroneous interpretation of the data. To avoid this artifact, we introduce z-scan FFS which consists of a fluorescence intensity z scan through the sample followed by an FFS measurement. To model the experimental z-scan data, a new PSF model had to be introduced. We use the intensity z scan together with the PSF model to determine the geometry of the sample and then extract the brightness from the FFS data. Cells expressing EGFP serve as a model system for testing the experimental approach. We demonstrate that z-scan FFS abolishes the brightness artifact and use the method to determine the oligomerization of cytoplasmic nuclear transport factor 2.

Chromophore maturation and fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy of fluorescent proteins in a cell-free expression system.

Cell-free synthesis, a method for the rapid expression of proteins, is increasingly used to study interactions of complex biological systems. GFP and its variants have become indispensable for fluorescence studies in live cells and are equally attractive as reporters for cell-free systems. This work investigates the use of fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (FFS) as a tool for quantitative analysis of protein interactions in cell-free expression systems. We also explore chromophore maturation of fluorescent proteins, which is of crucial importance for fluorescence studies. A droplet sample protocol was developed that ensured sufficient oxygenation for chromophore maturation and ease of manipulation for titration studies. The kinetics of chromophore maturation of EGFP, EYFP, and mCherry were analyzed as a function of temperature. A strong increase in the rate from room temperature to 37°C was observed. We further demonstrate that all EGFP proteins fully mature in the cell-free solution and that brightness is a robust parameter specifying stoichiometry. Finally, FFS is applied to study the stoichiometry of the nuclear transport factor 2 in a cell-free system over a broad concentration range. We conclude that combining cell-free expression and FFS provides a powerful technique for quick, quantitative study of chromophore maturation and protein-protein interaction.

Chapter Four - Brightness Analysis

Brightness analysis provides a powerful tool for the study of protein interactions both in solution and in living cells. We provide a brief survey of some widely used techniques for extracting brightness from fluorescent fluctuation spectroscopy experiments. While all the techniques are equivalent under ideal conditions, we touch upon their relative strengths and discuss in detail a specific scenario wherein the photon-counting histogram (PCH) separates the brightness of rare, bright particles from a dominant background. In a practical vein for ensuring quantitative and unbiased brightness data, we address a number of potential issues stemming from both theoretical assumptions and experimental realities. Two additional issues arising from geometry are examined in greater detail. An oil-immersion objective skews the geometry of the excitation volume as a function of penetration depth. The bias can be characterized and corrected or avoided through the use of a water-immersion objective. Brightness measurements in thin sample geometries, frequently encountered in cells, may be biased. We use z-scan FFS to characterize sample geometry and correct any resulting bias in the brightness.

Quantifying protein-protein interactions of peripheral membrane proteins by fluorescence brightness analysis

Fluorescently labeled proteins that are found both in the cytoplasm and at the plasma membrane, such as peripheral membrane proteins, create stratified fluorescent layers that present a challenging environment for brightness studies with fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy. The geometry of each layer along with fluorescence and brightness contributions from adjacent layers generates a convoluted raw brightness that conceals the underlying brightness of each individual layer. Because the brightness at a layer establishes the oligomeric state of the fluorescently labeled protein at said layer, we developed a method that connects the experimental raw brightness with the physical brightness at each layered compartment. The technique determines the oligomerization in each compartment from an axial intensity scan through the sample, followed by a fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy measurement at each layer. We experimentally verify the technique with H-Ras-EGFP as a model system and determine its oligomeric state at both the plasma membrane and in the cytoplasm. Furthermore, we study the oligomerization of the Gag matrix domain of Human T-lymphotropic virus Type 1. The matrix domain targets the Gag polyprotein to the plasma membrane where, subsequently, viral assembly occurs. We determine the oligomerization of matrix in the cytoplasm and observe the onset of protein-protein interactions at the membrane. These observations shed light on the early assembly steps of the retrovirus.

Quantitative measurement of brightness from living cells in the presence of photodepletion

The brightness of fluorescently labeled proteins provides an excellent marker for identifying protein interactions in living cells. Quantitative interpretation of brightness, however, hinges on a detailed understanding of the processes that affect the signal fluctuation of the fluorescent label. Here, we focus on the cumulative influence of photobleaching on brightness measurements in cells. Photobleaching within the finite volume of the cell leads to a depletion of the population of fluorescently labeled proteins with time. The process of photodepletion reduces the fluorescence signal which biases the analysis of brightness data. Our data show that even small reductions in the signal can introduce significant bias into the analysis of the data. We develop a model that quantifies the bias and introduce an analysis method that accurately determines brightness in the presence of photodepletion as verified by experiments with mammalian and yeast cells. In addition, photodepletion experiments with the fluorescent protein EGFP reveal the presence of a photoconversion process, which leads to a marked decrease in the brightness of the EGFP protein. We also identify conditions where the effect of EGFPs photoconversion on brightness experiments can be safely ignored.

Analysis of the HTLV-1 Gag assembly pathway by biophysical fluorescence

Much of the mechanistic details for how HTLV-1 Gag orchestrates virus particle assembly and release are poorly understood. Here, we monitored the behavior of both membrane-bound and cytoplasmic HTLV-1 Gag in real-time in living cells incubated on a fluorescence microscope. We used both fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (FFS, conventional and z-scan) and fluorescence imaging (epi-illumination, total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF)) to investigate the relationship between cytoplasmic and membrane bound Gag, using a Gag-YFP model system. FFS determines the brightness, mobility, and concentration (conventional) and localization (z-scan) of fluorescent particles from the intensity bursts generated by individual particles passing through a small observation volume, which yields information about protein stoichiometry, interactions, transport, and distribution. By coupling the single-molecule FFS technique with imaging techniques capable of monitoring Gag localization (epi-illumination) and membrane-specific localization (TIRF), we achieved new insights into the earliest events in HTLV-1 Gag assembly, and differences to HIV-1 Gag. We found that HTLV-1 Gag membrane-targeting occurred at all cytoplasmic concentrations measured, while appreciable membrane-targeting for HIV-1 required Gag cytoplasmic concentration to exceed a threshold. In addition, z-scan FFS revealed that a substantial population of membrane-bound HTLV-1 Gag exists not as puncta, but as a diffuse, low-order, dynamic “sheet.” These observations, coupled with previous observations of cytoplasmic Gag interactions and mobility, point to differences in membrane targeting of HTLV-1 and HIV-1 Gag. In summary, the suite of biophysical fluorescence techniques, applied HTLV-1 Gag, provide unparalleled information concerning HTLV-1 Gag trafficking processes in vivo, elucidating assembly pathway differences between HTLV-1 and other retroviruses.

Rhodamine-Derived Fluorescent Dye with Inherent Blinking Behavior for Super-Resolution Imaging

Super-resolution microscopy enables imaging of structures smaller than the diffraction limit. Single-molecule localization microscopy methods, such as photoactivation localization microscopy and stochastic optical reconstruction microscopy, reconstruct images by plotting the centroids of fluorescent point sources from a series of frames in which only a few molecules are fluorescing at a time. These approaches require simpler instrumentation than methods that depend on structured illumination and thus are becoming widespread. The functionalized rhodamine derivative reported in this paper spontaneously converts between a bright and dark state due to pH-dependent cyclization. At pH 7, less than 0.5% of the dye molecules are fluorescent at any given time. Blinking occurs on time scales of seconds to minutes and can therefore be used for single-molecule localization microscopy without sample treatment or activation. The dye is bright and straightforward to use, and it is easy to synthesize and functionalize. Thus, it has potential to become a new and powerful addition to the toolset for super-resolution imaging.