Shannon M. Anderson

New markers for murine memory B cells that define mutated and unmutated subsets

The study of murine memory B cells has been limited by small cell numbers and the lack of a definitive marker. We have addressed some of these difficulties with hapten-specific transgenic (Tg) mouse models that yield relatively large numbers of antigen-specific memory B cells upon immunization. Using these models, along with a 5-bromo-2′-deoxyuridine (BrdU) pulse-label strategy, we compared memory cells to their naive precursors in a comprehensive flow cytometric survey, thus revealing several new murine memory B cell markers. Most interestingly, memory cells were phenotypically heterogeneous. Particularly surprising was the finding of an unmutated memory B cell subset identified by the expression of CD80 and CD35. We confirmed these findings in an analogous V region knock-in mouse and/or in non-Tg mice. There also was anatomic heterogeneity, with BrdU+ memory cells residing not just in the marginal zone, as had been thought, but also in splenic follicles. These studies impact the current understanding of murine memory B cells by identifying new phenotypes and by challenging assumptions about the location and V region mutation status of memory cells. The apparent heterogeneity in the memory compartment implies either different origins and/or different functions, which we discuss.

Maintenance of the plasma cell pool is independent of memory B cells

Humoral memory to an antigen (Ag) is maintained for several decades in the form of memory B cells and serum Ab. In fact, plasma cells (PCs) that secrete Ab are known to be long-lived and could be solely responsible for maintaining the long-lived Ab titers. Alternatively, it has been proposed that the PC compartment is maintained for long periods by the differentiation of memory cells into long-lived PCs as a result of nonspecific stimulation. This model predicts accelerated decay of PC numbers in the absence of memory cells for the same Ag. To address this prediction, we have developed a mouse model system that combined the ability to deplete B cells with the ability to detect Ag-specific memory and PCs. After establishing an immune response, we depleted Ag-specific memory B cells with an anti-hCD20 mAb and determined the effect on the PC compartment over 16 weeks. Using a combination of surface markers, we demonstrated that memory B cells remained depleted over the course of the experiment. However, despite this absence of memory cells for an extended duration, PC numbers in spleen and bone marrow did not decline, which indicates that the PC compartment does not require a significant contribution from memory B cells for its maintenance and instead that PCs are sufficiently long-lived to maintain Ab titers over a long period without renewal. This observation settles an important controversy in B cell biology and has implications for the design of vaccines and for B cell depletion therapy in patients.

Cutting Edge: Hierarchy of Maturity of Murine Memory B Cell Subsets

The paucity of murine memory B cell markers has been a significant impediment to the study of memory. The most commonly used marker is IgG, which is neither sensitive nor specific, because activated nonmemory cells can be IgG+, and memory cells can be IgM+. In this article, we show that, together, PD-L2 (CD273), CD80, and CD73 define at least five phenotypic subsets of murine memory B cells. These subsets are generated from naive cells bearing a single BCR in response to a single T-dependent Ag. This diversity is independent of class switch, because IgG1- and IgM-bearing memory cells are found within each compartment. Memory subsets defined by PD-L2, CD80, and CD73 are biologically distinct from one another, because they differ in ontogeny and selection. Together, these distinctions suggest that there is a spectrum of memory B cells and progressive acquisition from more naive-like to more memory-like properties.

Taking Advantage: High-Affinity B Cells in the Germinal Center Have Lower Death Rates, but Similar Rates of Division, Compared to Low-Affinity Cells

B lymphocytes producing high-affinity Abs are critical for protection from extracellular pathogens, such as bacteria and parasites. The process by which high-affinity B cells are selected during the immune response has never been elucidated. Although it has been shown that high-affinity cells directly outcompete low-affinity cells in the germinal center (GC), whether there are also intrinsic differences between these cells has not been addressed. It could be that higher affinity cells proliferate more rapidly or are more likely to enter cell cycle, thereby outgrowing lower affinity cells. Alternatively, higher affinity cells could be relatively more resistant to cell death in the GC. By comparing high- and low-affinity B cells for the same Ag, we show here that low-affinity cells have an intrinsically higher death rate than do cells of higher affinity, even in the absence of competition. This suggests that selection in the GC reaction is due at least in part to the control of survival of higher affinity B cells and not by a proliferative advantage conferred upon these cells compared with lower affinity B cells. Control over survival rather than proliferation of low- and high-affinity B cells in the GC allows greater diversity not only in the primary response but also in the memory response.

Systematic Comparison of Gene Expression between Murine Memory and Naive B Cells Demonstrates That Memory B Cells Have Unique Signaling Capabilities

Memory B cells play essential roles in the maintenance of long-term immunity and may be important in the pathogenesis of autoimmune disease, but how these cells are distinguished from their naive precursors is poorly understood. To address this, it would be important to understand how gene expression differs between memory and naive B cells to elucidate memory-specific functions. Using model systems that help overcome the lack of murine memory-specific markers and the low frequency of Ag-specific memory and naive cells, we undertook a global comparison of gene expression between memory B cells and their naive precursors. We identified genes with differential expression and confirmed the differential expression of many of these by quantitative RT-PCR and of some of these at the protein level. Our initial analysis revealed differential expression patterns of genes that regulate signaling. Memory B cells have increased expression of genes important in regulating adenosine signaling and in modulating cAMP responses. Furthermore, memory B cells up-regulate receptors that are essential for embryonic stem cell self-renewal. We further demonstrate that one of these, leukemia inhibitory factor receptor, can initiate functional signaling in memory B cells whereas it does not in naive B cells. Thus, memory and naive B cells are intrinsically wired to signal differently from one another and express a functional signaling pathway that is known to maintain stem cells in other lineages.

CD80 Expression on B Cells Regulates Murine T Follicular Helper Development, Germinal Center B Cell Survival, and Plasma Cell Generation

Germinal center (GC) B cells and T follicular helper (TFH) cells interact in the production of high-affinity long-lived plasma cells (PCs) and memory B cells, although the mechanisms regulating the formation of these long-lived populations remain unclear. Because CD80 is one of the few markers shared by human and murine memory B cells, we investigated its role in the development of GCs, memory cells, and PCs. In CD80-deficient mice, fewer long-lived PCs were generated upon immunization compared with that in B6 controls. In concert, the absence of CD80 resulted in an increase in apoptotic GC B cells during the contraction phase of the GC. CD80−/− mice had fewer TFH cells compared with that of B6, and residual TFH cells failed to mature, with decreased ICOS and PD-1 expression and decreased synthesis of IL-21 mRNA. Mixed bone marrow chimeras demonstrated a B cell-intrinsic requirement for CD80 expression for normal TFH cell and PC development. Therefore, B cell expression of CD80 plays a critical role in regulating B–T interactions in both early and late GC responses. This, in turn, results in impaired ability to produce long-lived PCs. These data provide new insights into the development of GCs and Ab-forming cells and the functions of CD80 in humoral immunity.

Intrinsic properties of human and murine memory B cells.

Summary:  The central question of how the immune system responds in a qualitatively and quantitatively better way upon re‐exposure to a pathogen is largely unanswered. Both the increased frequency of antigen‐specific memory cells and the intrinsic properties that memory cells acquire after antigen experience could contribute to the faster and more robust responses seen after repeated exposure to antigen. In the case of the memory B‐cell response, it has been difficult to discern the individual contributions of these two effects. However, because of recent advances in identifying memory B cells, there is an increasing understanding of the intrinsic properties of these cells. The current insights into the unique properties of memory B cells and the progress that has been made in understanding how these affect secondary responses in both the human and the mouse systems are discussed. In addition, we compare the various advantages and disadvantages inherent in each of these systems, in terms of studying the intrinsic properties of memory B cells, and introduce the details of the system that we have developed using conventional heavy chain transgenic (Tgic) mice, which addresses some of the drawbacks of traditional memory models.

Cutting Edge: Memory B Cell Survival and Function in the Absence of Secreted Antibody and Immune Complexes on Follicular Dendritic Cells

Ag, in the form of immune complexes retained on follicular dendritic cells, has been implicated in the development and maintenance of B cell memory. We addressed this question using a H chain transgenic (Tg) mouse model that lacks secreted Ig (mIg), and thus does not deposit Ag-containing immune complexes. We compared the ability of the mIg strain and a control Tg strain, which secretes IgM, to develop and maintain long-lived memory cells. After immunization, there was an increase of Ag-specific B cells in both strains that was maintained for at least 20 wk. We labeled the long-lived Ag-specific cells with BrdU and found that this population was similarly maintained. In addition, both Tgs were able to maintain a functional memory response as measured by secondary germinal center reactions. Our studies indicate that localization of Ag on follicular dendritic cells is not necessary for development and maintenance of B cell memory.