Suzy Scholl

Age as prognostic factor in premenopausal breast carcinoma

Whether or not young age at diagnosis is an adverse prognostic factor in breast cancer has long been controversial, in part because much previous work has not taken due account of menopausal status and confounding factors. We have analysed the influence of age on prognosis in a consecutive series of 1703 patients with stage I-III breast cancer. All were premenopausal and all were treated in one centre (Institut Curie, Paris) between 1981 and 1985. Mean age was 44 years (range 23-55) and median follow-up was 82 months. Younger patients had significantly lower survival rates and higher local and distant relapse rates than older patients. The hazard rate of relapse decreased over time in the youngest age group (< or = 33) to reach that of older patients after 5 years. The relation between the hazard of recurrence and age was a continuous one, best fitted by a log-linear function and indicating a 4% decrease in recurrence for every year of age. Multivariate analysis of both survival and disease-free interval demonstrated that the worse prognosis of young age was independent of other factors such as clinical tumour size, clinical node status, histological grade, hormone receptor status, locoregional treatment procedure, and adjuvant systemic therapy. This difference in outlook has yet to be explained biologically but it does suggest the need for a closer look at the natural history of breast cancer in young women.

Neoadjuvant versus adjuvant chemotherapy in premenopausal patients with tumours considered too large for breast conserving surgery: Preliminary results of a randomised trial: S6

The aim of this study was to assess a potential advantage in survival by neoadjuvant as compared to adjuvant chemotherapy. 414 premenopausal patients with T2-T3 N0-N1 M0 breast cancer were randomised to receive either four cycles of neoadjuvant chemotherapy (cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, 5-fluorouracil), followed by local-regional treatment (group I) or four cycles of adjuvant chemotherapy after primary irradiation +/- surgery (group II). Surgery was limited to those patients with a persisting mass after irradiation, and aimed to be as conservative as possible. 390 patients were evaluable. With a median follow-up of 54 months, we observed a statistically significant difference (P = 0.039) in survival in favour of the neoadjuvant chemotherapy group. A similar trend was seen when the time to metastatic recurrence was evaluated (P = 0.09). At this stage, no difference in disease-free interval or local recurrence between these two groups could be observed. The mean total dose of chemotherapy administered was similar in both groups. On average, group I had more intensive chemotherapy regimes (doxorubicin P = 0.02) but fewer treatment courses (P = 0.008) as compared to the treated patients in group II. Haematological tolerance was reduced when chemotherapy succeeded to exclusive irradiation. Breast conservation was identical for both groups at the end of primary treatment (82 and 77% for groups I and II, respectively). Of the 191 evaluable patients in the neoadjuvant treatment arm, 65% had an objective response (> 50% regression) following four cycles of chemotherapy. The objective response rate to primary irradiation (55 Gy) was 85%. Improved survival figures in the neoadjuvant treatment arm could be the result of the early initiation of chemotherapy, but we cannot exclude that this difference might be attributable to a slightly more aggressive treatment. So far, the trend in favour of decreased metastases was not statistically significant. The local control appeared similar in both subgroups.

Therapeutic vaccines for cancer: an overview of clinical trials

The therapeutic potential of host-specific and tumour-specific immune responses is well recognized and, after many years, active immunotherapies directed at inducing or augmenting these responses are entering clinical practice. Antitumour immunization is a complex, multi-component task, and the optimal combinations of antigens, adjuvants, delivery vehicles and routes of administration are not yet identified. Active immunotherapy must also address the immunosuppressive and tolerogenic mechanisms deployed by tumours. This Review provides an overview of new results from clinical studies of therapeutic cancer vaccines directed against tumour-associated antigens and discusses their implications for the use of active immunotherapy.

Contralateral breast cancer: annual incidence and risk parameters.

PURPOSE To screen for factors that might predict the risk of developing metachronous contralateral breast cancer (CBC), taking into account the influence of local or distant recurrence, and to assess the annual incidence of CBC. PATIENTS AND METHODS Of 4,748 women with invasive unilateral breast cancer, clinical stage I to IIIa, treated between 1981 and 1987, 282 metachronous CBCs were diagnosed. Due to competing risks between the occurrence of CBC and other events, several options for multivariate analysis were considered. RESULTS The median follow-up time was 80 months (range, 1 to 158). The cumulative rate of CBC was 4.1% +/- 0.3% at 5 years, and the annual incidence rate of CBC increased slowly, while the risk of local recurrence and metastases decreased after the fourth year. Whichever model we chose, age less than 55 years (relative risk [RR] = 1.40) at the time of diagnosis of the first breast cancer, as well as the presence of lobular type carcinoma (RR = 1.50), was associated with an increased risk of developing a tumor in the contralateral breast. Adjuvant chemotherapy significantly decreased (RR = 0.54) the risk of CBC. CONCLUSION Lobular histology and age less than 55 years are found to increase the risk of CBC, while adjuvant chemotherapy significantly decreased the risk of CBC. The progressive rise in the annual incidence rates of CBC, together with the absence of a link between clinical prognostic factors of the first cancer and CBC, suggested that CBC can be considered as a second primary breast cancer.

BREAST TUMOUR RESPONSE TO PRIMARY CHEMOTHERAPY PREDICTS LOCAL AND DISTANT CONTROL AS WELL AS SURVIVAL

The purpose of the present paper was to evaluate correlations between clinical response to chemotherapy and outcome in a subgroup analysis of premenopausal patients with tumours considered too large for breast conserving surgery, treated with primary chemotherapy (n = 200) from a previously published trial (Scholl S.M., Fourquet A., Asselain B, et al. Eur J Cancer 1994, 30A, 645-652). Objective response rates amounted to 65% following four courses. In a multivariate Cox regression analysis, comparing seven parameters, the following variables were associated with poor survival: clinically involved nodes [N1b:RR: 2.7 (95% CI 1.3-5.3)], the failure to respond to chemotherapy [D:RR: 2.62 (95% CI 1.3-5)] and a raised S phase fraction [SPF > 5%: RR: 2.4 (95% CI 1.2-5)]. Parameters associated with increased metastatic recurrence rates, by order of entry in the model, were: young age [< 35: RR: 2.46 (95% CI 1.2-5)], large clinical tumour size [T3: RR: 2.02 (95% CI 1.2-3.4)], poor histological grade (SBR III: RR: 1.93 (95% CI 1.1-3.3)] and the failure to respond to chemotherapy [D: RR: 1.91 (95% CI 1-3.4)]. The assessment of both tumour cell proliferation rates as well as possibly drug resistance markers (although not available in the present study) should be helpful in selecting patients likely to benefit from intensified chemotherapy regimens. The most accurate predictor of response in the present study appeared to be the response to chemotherapy treatment itself.

Prognostic factors in inflammatory breast cancer and therapeutic implications

223 inflammatory breast cancer patients were diagnosed at the Institut Curie between 1977 and 1987. Patients received chemotherapy and radiation treatment according to three consecutive randomised trials. Five- and 10- year survival rates were 41 and 32%, respectively. Disease-free interval rates were 25.5% at 5 years and 19% at 10 years. Parameters significantly linked with a pejorative prognosis in a multivariate analysis were: diffuse erythema, lymph node involvement, chest wall adherence, and age above 50 years. When therapeutic response parameters were included in the multivariate analysis, the five most important prognostic factors in order of significance were complete tumour regression after completion of induction treatment (at 8 months), complete regression of inflammatory symptoms after 3 months of neoadjuvant chemotherapy, limited erythema at presentation and, less significantly, complete regression of inflammatory symptoms at 8 months and tumour regression at 3 months. In conclusion, patients who achieved a rapid and complete remission had a better prognosis than patients who had an incomplete response to chemotherapy. High-dose chemotherapy and reversal or prevention of drug resistance will be evaluated in future trials. Detailed information on the biology of this disease should allow the design of new strategies aiming to improve patient management.

Regression of high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia with TG4001 targeted immunotherapy

OBJECTIVE We sought to evaluate the safety and efficacy of TG4001 in patients with human papillomavirus (HPV) 16-related cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 2/3 at 6 and 12 months. STUDY DESIGN In all, 21 patients with HPV 16-related CIN 2/3 received 3 weekly subcutaneous injections of TG4001. Regression of the CIN 2/3 lesion and the clearance of HPV 16 infection were monitored by cytology, colposcopy, and HPV DNA/messenger RNA (mRNA) detection. A clinical response was defined by no CIN 2/3 found on conization, or no conization performed because not suspected at cytology or colposcopy. RESULTS Ten patients (48%) were evaluated as clinical responders at month 6. Nine patients experienced an improvement of their HPV 16 infection, by mRNA ± DNA eradication. HPV 16 mRNA clearance was associated with CIN 2/3 cytologic and colposcopic regression in 7 of 10 patients. At month 12, 7 of 8 patients without conization reported neither suspicion of CIN 2/3 relapse nor HPV 16 infection. The remaining patient was lost to follow-up. CONCLUSION These promising data warrant further development of TG4001 in CIN 2/3 treatment.

Simultaneous bilateral breast carcinomas: A retrospective review of 149 cases☆

PURPOSE To evaluate clinical and biological characteristics as well as treatment outcome in simultaneous bilateral breast carcinomas. METHODS AND MATERIALS Between 1981 and 1990, 149 patients were diagnosed to have simultaneous bilateral breast carcinoma, defined as tumor arising in both breasts within a maximum of a 6-month interval, in the absence of distant metastases. The median age was 58. Out of a total of 298 tumors, the clinical tumor size was T0-T1 in 40%, T2 in 45%, and T3-T4 in 15% of tumors. The majority of patients (83%) were clinically node negative. Seventy-eight percent of all tumors were classified ductal invasive; 6% were invasive lobular carcinomas; in situ tumors were present in 9%. More than two-thirds of all tumors were well or moderately well differentiated. Tumors were estrogen positive in 86% and progesterone positive in 69% of 62% of patients for whom this information was available in both tumors. Treatment had been by bilateral mastectomy in 43%, by exclusive irradiation in 16%, and by combined surgery and radiation in 41%. RESULTS Median follow-up was 68 months (11-141). A number of positive correlations existed between the tumors in both breasts more often than by chance alone: These were the presence of lobular carcinomas in both breasts (p = 0.06), the same histological grade (p = 0.002), similar ER (p = 0.03) and PR (p = 0.01) status. Five-year rates for survival and disease-free interval were 86% (80-92) and 70% (62-78), respectively. For each patient the stage of the largest tumor at diagnosis was defined as maximum stage. When survival figures were compared between each maximum stage and matched stages of a group of unilateral breast cancer patients treated during the same time interval in our institute, bilateral breast cancer fared not worse than unilateral breast tumors. Treatment related complications occurred in eight patients (5%). CONCLUSION Simultaneous bilateral breast carcinomas have similar biological, but not clinical, features more frequently than would be predicted by chance alone. So far, the number of patients is too small, and the follow-up is too short to determine whether or not the prognosis is equivalent to that of unilateral breast cancer patients of equal stage. Bilateral conservative treatment is feasible with acceptable cosmetic results and toxicity by using carefully designed radiotherapy techniques.

Response to chemotherapy is a major parameter-influencing long-term survival of metastatic breast cancer patients

BACKGROUND In cancer patients, correlation between response to chemotherapy and gain in survival remains debated. We addressed this question in a multivariate analysis evaluating response to chemotherapy as a factor influencing survival of patients with metastatic breast cancer. PATIENTS AND METHODS From 1977 to 1992, 1430 patients included in eight consecutive prospective trials of anthracycline-based first-line chemotherapy in metastatic breast cancer, were available for assessment. Median follow-up was 155 months. RESULTS Median survival from the date of randomisation was 24 months. Objective response rate was 63.6%. A complete response (CR) was achieved in 17% (249 patients). In a stepwise forward progression analysis objective response was the first independent prognostic factor for survival. Median survival time was 43 months for complete responders (CR), 29 months for partial responders (PR), 18 months for stable disease (SD), 5 months for progressive disease (PD). The probability of survival at 5 and 10 years was 35% and 15% for CRs and decreased to 18% and 6% for PRs. The timing of best response (at 4 or 8 months) was not related to outcome. CONCLUSIONS Response to an anthracycline-based chemotherapy is a major independent prognostic factor in metastatic breast cancer. The use of this factor to investigate new drugs seems to be pertinent. The good prognosis of complete responders justifies further evaluation of new treatment strategies for this patient population.

Predictive factors of response to first-line chemotherapy in 1426 women with metastatic breast cancer.

Since response to chemotherapy is a major determinant of survival in metastatic breast cancer, the purpose of our study was to analyse the predictive factors of response. 1426 patients enrolled into eight consecutive randomised trials of anthracycline-based first-line chemotherapy in metastatic breast cancer, between 1977 and 1992, were analysed. A forward stepwise logistic regression analysis was used. The objective response rate (ORR) to chemotherapy in the total population was 63.6% (95% confidence interval (CI): 61.5-67.7). The complete response rate was 17.5%. Multivariate analysis defined adjuvant chemotherapy, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), Karnofsky index (KI), and pleural and lung metastases to be the five main variables correlated with ORR. A predictive score was calculated using the coefficient of these five variables, The score was established as follows: -1.32+0.54 (if prior adjuvant chemotherapy) +0.80 (low KI) +0.75 (raised LDH) +0.49 (lung metastases) +0.51 (pleural metastases). A low score (less than -0.78) was associated with an ORR greater than 70.0%, representing 41.2% of our population. An intermediate score (between -0.78 and 0) was associated with an ORR of 50 to 70%, representing 37.5% of our population and a positive score was associated with an ORR of less than 50%, representing 21.3% of our population. This score can be used to predict objective response rates to first-line anthracycline-based chemotherapy. This method now needs to be evaluated prospectively in phase II trials. Identification of various risk groups may also be useful for interpretation and design of clinical trials.