Thomas Breitenbach

Singlet Oxygen Sensor Green®: Photochemical Behavior in Solution and in a Mammalian Cell

The development of efficient and selective luminescent probes for reactive oxygen species, particularly for singlet molecular oxygen, is currently of great importance. In this study, the photochemical behavior of Singlet Oxygen Sensor Green® (SOSG), a commercially available fluorescent probe for singlet oxygen, was examined. Despite published claims to the contrary, the data presented herein indicate that SOSG can, in fact, be incorporated into a living mammalian cell. However, for a number of reasons, caution must be exercised when using SOSG. First, it is shown that the immediate product of the reaction between SOSG and singlet oxygen is, itself, an efficient singlet oxygen photosensitizer. Second, SOSG appears to efficiently bind to proteins which, in turn, can influence uptake by a cell as well as behavior in the cell. As such, incorrect use of SOSG can yield misleading data on yields of photosensitized singlet oxygen production, and can also lead to photooxygenation‐dependent adverse effects in the system being investigated.

Oxygen-dependent photochemistry and photophysics of "miniSOG," a protein-encased flavin.

Selected photochemical and photophysical parameters of flavin mononucleotide (FMN) have been examined under conditions in which FMN is (1) solvated in a buffered aqueous solution, and (2) encased in a protein likewise solvated in a buffered aqueous solution. The latter was achieved using the so‐called “mini Singlet Oxygen Generator” (miniSOG), an FMN‐containing flavoprotein engineered from Arabidopsis thaliana phototropin 2. Although FMN is a reasonably good singlet oxygen photosensitizer in bulk water (ϕΔ = 0.65 ± 0.04), enclosing FMN in this protein facilitates photoinitiated electron‐transfer reactions (Type‐I chemistry) at the expense of photosensitized singlet oxygen production (Type‐II chemistry) and results in a comparatively poor yield of singlet oxygen (ϕΔ = 0.030 ± 0.002). This observation on the effect of the local environment surrounding FMN is supported by a host of spectroscopic and chemical trapping experiments. The results of this study not only elucidate the behavior of miniSOG but also provide useful information for the further development of well‐characterized chromophores suitable for use as intracellular sensitizers in mechanistic studies of reactive oxygen species.

Corneal Distribution of Riboflavin Prior to Collagen Cross-Linking

Purpose: To evaluate the distribution of riboflavin in the corneal stroma, under varying concentrations and application time. Materials and Methods: In 54 porcine eyes, the central corneal epithelium was removed, and 0.035, 0.1, or 0.2% riboflavin-5-phosphate (in 20% Dextran T-500) was applied for 10, 20, or 30 min (3 × 6 corneas in each of the 3 groups). Trephined corneal buttons were examined using confocal fluorescence microscopy. Stromal riboflavin distribution and concentration was determined by measuring riboflavin fluorescence in optical sections at 10 µm intervals through the entire cornea. The procedure was repeated in 7 human corneal donor grafts using 0.1% riboflavin-5-phosphate for 20 or 30 min. Results: In porcine corneas, fluorescence intensity peaked within the first 50 µm followed by a steep decline to baseline. Increasing the riboflavin concentration from 0.1 to 0.2% did not increase stromal depth propagation, although a higher concentration in the anterior 200 µm was observed. Reducing the riboflavin application time from 30 to 20 min had no impact on corneal depth propagation or total riboflavin uptake. However, a 10-min further reduction of the application time caused a significantly reduced riboflavin uptake. In all human corneas, fluorescence peaked within the anterior 50 µm, followed by a steep decline to baseline over the next 200 µm; similar to the observations in porcine corneas. The human corneas imbibed more riboflavin compared to the porcine corneas. Conclusions: In human and porcine corneas, riboflavin does not appear to fully load the corneal stroma using the current clinical procedure. Instead, the uptake appears to be limited to the anterior approximately 200 µm. Changes in application time and riboflavin concentration have only little influence on stromal depth diffusion.

Aarhus Sensor Green: A Fluorescent Probe for Singlet Oxygen

A tetrafluoro-substituted fluorescein derivative covalently linked to a 9,10-diphenyl anthracene moiety has been synthesized, and its photophysical properties have been characterized. This compound, denoted Aarhus Sensor Green (ASG), has distinct advantages for use as a fluorescent probe for singlet molecular oxygen, O2(a(1)Δg). In the least, ASG overcomes several limitations inherent to the use of the related commercially available product called Singlet Oxygen Sensor Green (SOSG). The functional behavior of both ASG and SOSG derives from the fact that these weakly fluorescent compounds rapidly react with singlet oxygen via a π2 + π4 cycloaddition to irreversibly yield a highly fluorescent endoperoxide. The principal advantage of ASG over SOSG is that, at physiological pH values, both ASG and the ASG endoperoxide (ASG-EP) do not themselves photosensitize the production of singlet oxygen. As such, ASG better fits the requirement of being a benign probe. Although ASG readily enters a mammalian cell (i.e., HeLa) and responds to the presence of intracellular singlet oxygen, its behavior in this arguably complicated environment requires further investigation.

Singlet-Oxygen-Mediated Cell Death Using Spatially-Localized Two-Photon Excitation of an Extracellular Sensitizer

Controlling and quantifying the photosensitized production of singlet oxygen are key aspects in mechanistic studies of oxygen-dependent photoinitiated cell death. In this regard, the commonly accepted practice of using intracellular photosensitizers is, unfortunately, plagued by problems that include the inability to accurately (1) quantify the sensitizer concentration in the irradiated domain and (2) control the local environment that influences light delivery and sensitizer photophysics. However, capitalizing on the fact that singlet oxygen produced outside a cell is also cytotoxic, many of these problems can be avoided with the use of an extracellular sensitizer. For the present study, a hydrophilic dendrimer-encased membrane-impermeable sensitizer was used to generate an extracellular population of singlet oxygen upon spatially localized two-photon irradiation. Through the use of this sensitizer and this approach, it is now possible to better control the singlet oxygen dose in microscope-based time- and space-resolved single cell experiments. Thus, we provide a solution to a limiting problem in mechanistic studies of singlet-oxygen-mediated cell death.

Two-photon irradiation of an intracellular singlet oxygen photosensitizer: Achieving localized sub-cellular excitation in spatially-resolved experiments

Abstract The response of a given cell to spatially-resolved sub-cellular irradiation of a singlet oxygen photosensitizer (protoporphyrin IX, PpIX) using a focused laser was assessed. In these experiments, incident light was scattered over a volume greater than that defined by the dimensions of the laser beam as a consequence of the inherent inhomogeneity of the cell. Upon irradiation at a wavelength readily absorbed by PpIX in a one-photon transition, this scattering of light eliminated any advantage accrued to the use of focused irradiation. However, upon irradiation at a longer wavelength where PpIX can only absorb light under non-linear two-photon conditions, meaningful intracellular resolution was achieved in the small spatial domain where the light intensity was high enough for absorption to occur.

Antioxidant β-carotene does not quench singlet oxygen in mammalian cells.

Carotenoids, and β-carotene in particular, are important natural antioxidants. Singlet oxygen, the lowest excited state of molecular oxygen, is an intermediate often involved in natural oxidation reactions. The fact that β-carotene efficiently quenches singlet oxygen in solution-phase systems is invariably invoked when explaining the biological antioxidative properties of β-carotene. We recently developed unique microscope-based time-resolved spectroscopic methods that allow us to directly examine singlet oxygen in mammalian cells. We now demonstrate that intracellular singlet oxygen, produced in a photosensitized process, is in fact not efficiently deactivated by β-carotene. This observation requires a re-evaluation of β-carotenes role as an antioxidant in mammalian systems and now underscores the importance of mechanisms by which β-carotene inhibits radical reactions.

Spatially resolved two-photon irradiation of an intracellular singlet oxygen photosensitizer: Correlating cell response to the site of localized irradiation

Abstract The response of HeLa cells to subcellular spatially localized two-photon irradiation of a singlet oxygen photosensitizer (protoporphyrin IX, PpIX) using a focused laser was assessed. Upon irradiation under these conditions, a localized population of PpIX excited states can be produced with meaningful intracellular spatial resolution; the dimensions of the domain where the incident light flux is high enough for PpIX two-photon absorption are defined by the microscope optics and by the diffraction of light (spot diameter at beam waist of ˜0.5–1.0 μm). In turn, the dimensions of the intracellular domain containing cytotoxic PpIX-sensitized singlet oxygen will likewise be confined. Most importantly, cell response (e.g., morphological signs of cell death) correlates with the light dose delivered and the intracellular domain irradiated. Thus, controlling light delivery can complement other techniques used to impart intracellular spatial localization in mechanistic studies of photoinitiated reactive oxygen species. Such controlled light delivery is also expected to be a particularly useful tool to study the so-called bystander effect in which a selectively-perturbed cell can influence a neighboring cell through intercellular signaling mechanisms.

Singlet oxygen-sensitized delayed fluorescence of common water-soluble photosensitizers

Six common water-soluble singlet oxygen ((1)O2) photosensitizers - 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(1-methyl-4-pyridinio) porphine (TMPyP), meso-tetrakis(4-sulfonathophenyl)porphine (TPPS4), Al(III) phthalocyanine chloride tetrasulfonic acid (AlPcS4), eosin Y, rose bengal, and methylene blue - were investigated in terms of their ability to produce delayed fluorescence (DF) in solutions at room temperature. All the photosensitizers dissolved in air-saturated phosphate buffered saline (PBS, pH 7.4) exhibit easily detectable DF, which can be nearly completely quenched by 10 mM NaN3, a specific (1)O2 quencher. The DF kinetics has a biexponential rise-decay character in a microsecond time domain. Therefore, we propose that singlet oxygen-sensitized delayed fluorescence (SOSDF), where the triplet state of a photosensitizer reacts with (1)O2 giving rise to an excited singlet state of the photosensitizer, is the prevailing mechanism. It was confirmed by additional evidence, such as a monoexponential decay of triplet-triplet transient absorption kinetics, dependence of SOSDF kinetics on oxygen concentration, absence of SOSDF in a nitrogen-saturated sample, or the effect of isotopic exchange H2O-D2O. Eosin Y and AlPcS4 show the largest SOSDF quantum yield among the selected photosensitizers, whereas rose bengal possesses the highest ratio of SOSDF intensity to prompt fluorescence intensity. The rate constant for the reaction of triplet state with (1)O2 giving rise to the excited singlet state of photosensitizer was estimated to be ~/>1 × 10(9) M(-1) s(-1). SOSDF kinetics contains information about both triplet and (1)O2 lifetimes and concentrations, which makes it a very useful alternative tool for monitoring photosensitizing and (1)O2 quenching processes, allowing its detection in the visible spectral region, utilizing the photosensitizer itself as a (1)O2 probe. Under our experimental conditions, SOSDF was up to three orders of magnitude more intense than the infrared (1)O2 phosphorescence and by far the most important pathway of DF. SOSDF was also detected in a suspension of 3T3 mouse fibroblast cells, which underlines the importance of SOSDF and its relevance for biological systems.

Single Cell Responses to Spatially Controlled Photosensitized Production of Extracellular Singlet Oxygen

The response of individual HeLa cells to extracellularly produced singlet oxygen was examined. The spatial domain of singlet oxygen production was controlled using the combination of a membrane‐impermeable Pd porphyrin‐dendrimer, which served as a photosensitizer, and a focused laser, which served to localize the sensitized production of singlet oxygen. Cells in close proximity to the domain of singlet oxygen production showed morphological changes commonly associated with necrotic cell death. The elapsed postirradiation “waiting period” before necrosis became apparent depended on: (1) the distance between the cell membrane and the domain irradiated, (2) the incident laser fluence and, as such, the initial concentration of singlet oxygen produced and (3) the lifetime of singlet oxygen. The data imply that singlet oxygen plays a key role in this process of light‐induced cell death. The approach of using extracellularly generated singlet oxygen to induce cell death can provide a solution to a problem that often limits mechanistic studies of intracellularly photosensitized cell death: it can be difficult to quantify the effective light dose, and hence singlet oxygen concentration, when using an intracellular photosensitizer.