Tyani D. Chan

Antigen recognition strength regulates the choice between extrafollicular plasma cell and germinal center B cell differentiation

B cells responding to T-dependent antigen either differentiate rapidly into extrafollicular plasma cells or enter germinal centers and undergo somatic hypermutation and affinity maturation. However, the physiological cues that direct B cell differentiation down one pathway versus the other are unknown. Here we show that the strength of the initial interaction between B cell receptor (BCR) and antigen is a primary determinant of this decision. B cells expressing a defined BCR specificity for hen egg lysozyme (HEL) were challenged with sheep red blood cell conjugates of a series of recombinant mutant HEL proteins engineered to bind this BCR over a 10,000-fold affinity range. Decreasing either initial BCR affinity or antigen density was found to selectively remove the extrafollicular plasma cell response but leave the germinal center response intact. Moreover, analysis of competing B cells revealed that high affinity specificities are more prevalent in the extrafollicular plasma cell versus the germinal center B cell response. Thus, the effectiveness of early T-dependent antibody responses is optimized by preferentially steering B cells reactive against either high affinity or abundant epitopes toward extrafollicular plasma cell differentiation. Conversely, responding clones with weaker antigen reactivity are primarily directed to germinal centers where they undergo affinity maturation.

B cell-intrinsic signaling through IL-21 receptor and STAT3 is required for establishing long-lived antibody responses in humans.

Engagement of cytokine receptors by specific ligands activate Janus kinase–signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT) signaling pathways. The exact roles of STATs in human lymphocyte behavior remain incompletely defined. Interleukin (IL)-21 activates STAT1 and STAT3 and has emerged as a potent regulator of B cell differentiation. We have studied patients with inactivating mutations in STAT1 or STAT3 to dissect their contribution to B cell function in vivo and in response to IL-21 in vitro. STAT3 mutations dramatically reduced the number of functional, antigen (Ag)-specific memory B cells and abolished the ability of IL-21 to induce naive B cells to differentiate into plasma cells (PCs). This resulted from impaired activation of the molecular machinery required for PC generation. In contrast, STAT1 deficiency had no effect on memory B cell formation in vivo or IL-21–induced immunoglobulin secretion in vitro. Thus, STAT3 plays a critical role in generating effector B cells from naive precursors in humans. STAT3-activating cytokines such as IL-21 thus underpin Ag-specific humoral immune responses and provide a mechanism for the functional antibody deficit in STAT3-deficient patients.

High affinity germinal center B cells are actively selected into the plasma cell compartment

A hallmark of T cell–dependent immune responses is the progressive increase in the ability of serum antibodies to bind antigen and provide immune protection. Affinity maturation of the antibody response is thought to be connected with the preferential survival of germinal centre (GC) B cells that have acquired increased affinity for antigen via somatic hypermutation of their immunoglobulin genes. However, the mechanisms that drive affinity maturation remain obscure because of the difficulty in tracking the affinity-based selection of GC B cells and their differentiation into plasma cells. We describe a powerful new model that allows these processes to be followed as they occur in vivo. In contrast to evidence from in vitro systems, responding GC B cells do not undergo plasma cell differentiation stochastically. Rather, only GC B cells that have acquired high affinity for the immunizing antigen form plasma cells. Affinity maturation is therefore driven by a tightly controlled mechanism that ensures only antibodies with the greatest possibility of neutralizing foreign antigen are produced. Because the body can sustain only limited numbers of plasma cells, this “quality control” over plasma cell differentiation is likely critical for establishing effective humoral immunity.

Dock8 mutations cripple B cell immunological synapses, germinal centers and long-lived antibody production

To identify genes and mechanisms involved in humoral immunity, we did a mouse genetic screen for mutations that do not affect the first wave of antibody to immunization but disrupt response maturation and persistence. The first two mutants identified had loss-of-function mutations in the gene encoding a previously obscure member of a family of Rho-Rac GTP-exchange factors, DOCK8. DOCK8-mutant B cells were unable to form marginal zone B cells or to persist in germinal centers and undergo affinity maturation. Dock8 mutations disrupted accumulation of the integrin ligand ICAM-1 in the B cell immunological synapse but did not alter other aspects of B cell antigen receptor signaling. Humoral immunodeficiency due to Dock8 mutation provides evidence that organization of the immunological synapse is critical for signaling the survival of B cell subsets required for long-lasting immunity.

Antigen Affinity Controls Rapid T-Dependent Antibody Production by Driving the Expansion Rather than the Differentiation or Extrafollicular Migration of Early Plasmablasts

To optimize the initial wave of Ab production against T-dependent Ags, primary B cell clones with the highest Ag affinity are selected to generate the largest extrafollicular plasmablast (PB) responses. The mechanism behind this remains undefined, primarily due to the difficulty of analyzing low frequency Ag-specific B cells during the earliest phases of the immune response when key differentiation decisions are made. In this study, a high resolution in vivo mouse model was used to characterize in detail the first 6 days of a T-dependent B cell response and to identify the steps at which initial Ag affinity has a major impact. Ag-specific B cells proliferated within splenic follicles from days 1.0 to 3.0 before undergoing a dynamic phase of multilineage differentiation (days 3.0–4.0) that generated switched and unswitched populations of germinal center B cells, early memory B cells, and extrafollicular PBs. PB differentiation was marked by synchronous up-regulation of CXCR4 and down-regulation of CXCR5 and the adoption of a unique BCRhigh phenotype by unswitched PBs. Differences in Ag affinity of >50-fold did not markedly affect the early stages of the response, including the differentiation and extrafollicular migration of PBs. However, high affinity PBs underwent significantly greater expansion within the splenic bridging channels and red pulp, due to both increased proliferation and decreased apoptosis. Extrafollicular PBs maintained class II MHC, but not IL-21R expression, and interacted directly with Ag-specific extrafollicular Th cells, suggesting that IL-21-independent T cell help may drive extrafollicular PB expansion in responses to foreign Ag.

Redemption of autoantibodies on anergic B cells by variable-region glycosylation and mutation away from self-reactivity.

Significance Antibodies are selected to bind microbial but not self-antigens, because binding to self would compete with binding microbes, shorten antibody half-life, and cause autoimmunity. Self-tolerance is actively acquired in part by discarding self-binding antibodies before the body is exposed to a microbe or vaccine. The experiments here provide evidence of an opposite mechanism, allowing antibodies that initially bind both foreign and self-antigens to acquire self/non-self discrimination during the course of an immune response through somatic hypermutation away from self-reactivity. In addition to selection for lower-affinity binding to self, antibody variants were selected with fewer binding sites available to bind self-antigen because most were occupied by N-linked carbohydrate, possibly explaining the frequent occurrence of N-linked glycosylation of antibody variable domains. The best-understood mechanisms for achieving antibody self/non-self discrimination discard self-reactive antibodies before they can be tested for binding microbial antigens, potentially creating holes in the repertoire. Here we provide evidence for a complementary mechanism: retaining autoantibodies in the repertoire displayed as low levels of IgM and high IgD on anergic B cells, masking a varying proportion of autoantibody-binding sites with carbohydrates, and removing their self-reactivity by somatic hypermutation and selection in germinal centers (GCs). Analysis of human antibody sequences by deep sequencing of isotype-switched memory B cells or in IgG antibodies elicited against allogeneic RhD+ erythrocytes, vaccinia virus, rotavirus, or tetanus toxoid provides evidence for reactivation of anergic IgMlow IgD+ IGHV4-34+ B cells and removal of cold agglutinin self-reactivity by hypermutation, often accompanied by mutations that inactivated an N-linked glycosylation sequon in complementarity-determining region 2 (CDR2). In a Hy10 antibody transgenic model where anergic B cells respond to a biophysically defined lysozyme epitope displayed on both foreign and self-antigens, cell transfers revealed that anergic IgMlow IgD+ B cells form twice as many GC progeny as naïve IgMhi IgD+ counterparts. Their GC progeny were rapidly selected for CDR2 mutations that blocked 72% of antigen-binding sites with N-linked glycan, decreased affinity 100-fold, and then cleared the binding sites of blocking glycan. These results provide evidence for a mechanism to acquire self/non-self discrimination by somatic mutation away from self-reactivity, and reveal how varying the efficiency of N-glycosylation provides a mechanism to modulate antibody avidity.

Affinity-based selection and the germinal center response

Summary:  Interactions between B‐cell antigen receptors (BCRs) and their ligands have a complexity and variability that is unparalleled within known biology. Each developing B cell undergoes gene rearrangements to generate a BCR encoded by a unique pair of immunoglobulin (Ig) variable region genes, which serves to make the antigen‐binding capabilities of primary BCRs incredibly diverse. Further diversification of the BCR repertoire takes place when antigen‐activated B cells enter the germinal center (GC) response and undergo somatic hypermutation (SHM) of their Ig variable region genes. To develop optimal antibody responses against foreign antigens, the key B‐cell survival and differentiation decisions made in the GC are based primarily on the affinity of the BCR (and therefore subsequent antibodies) for foreign antigen. However, the secondary diversification of BCRs by SHM also carries the risk of generating new self‐reactive specificities and thus autoantibody production. Herein, we review the role of antigen affinity/avidity in controlling pivotal events both leading up to and during the GC response. The emergence of self‐reactivity during the GC response is also examined, with particular focus on the threat posed by cross‐reactive GC B cells that bind both self and foreign antigen.

Elimination of Germinal-Center-Derived Self-Reactive B Cells Is Governed by the Location and Concentration of Self-Antigen

Secondary diversification of the B cell repertoire by immunoglobulin gene somatic hypermutation in the germinal center (GC) is essential for providing the high-affinity antibody specificities required for long-term humoral immunity. While the risk to self-tolerance posed by inadvertent generation of self-reactive GC B cells has long been recognized, it has not previously been possible to identify such cells and study their fate. In the current study, self-reactive B cells generated de novo in the GC failed to survive when their target self-antigen was either expressed ubiquitously or specifically in cells proximal to the GC microenvironment. By contrast, GC B cells that recognized rare or tissue-specific self-antigens were not eliminated, and could instead undergo positive selection by cross-reactive foreign antigen and produce plasma cells secreting high-affinity autoantibodies. These findings demonstrate the incomplete nature of GC self-tolerance and may explain the frequent association of cross-reactive, organ-specific autoantibodies with postinfectious autoimmune disease.

Visualizing the effects of antigen affinity on T-dependent B-cell differentiation.

Burnets original description of the clonal selection hypothesis of antibody production included many prescient predictions of how ‘lymphocytes carrying reactive sites’ for foreign antigens might respond during immune responses. Somatic mutation, plasma cell differentiation and transition into memory cells were all described as potential fates for the ‘variety of descendents’ derived from proliferative expansion of antigen‐reactive clones. After 50 years much is known about the molecular controls that drive these various processes. Comparatively little insight has been gained, however, into why particular daughter cells progress down one response pathway versus another. In this article, we briefly describe the evolution of the genetic technologies that now allow us to visualize the very processes predicted by Burnet. An in‐depth description of the recently developed SWHEL mouse model and its utility for tracking in vivo B‐cell responses to various forms of hen‐egg lysozyme (HEL) is also provided. Recent data obtained with this system indicate that antigen‐dependent variables play a critical role in regulating the differentiation of responding B cells into antibody‐secreting plasma cells.

In vivo control of B-cell survival and antigen-specific B-cell responses

Summary:  Targeted modification of the mouse genome provides the capability to manipulate complex physiological processes in a precise and controlled manner. Investigation of B‐lymphocyte biology has benefited not only from the targeted modification of genes controlling B‐cell survival and responsiveness, but also from the manipulation of antigen specificity made possible by targeting endogenous immunoglobulin loci. In this review, we discuss recent results obtained from our laboratory using gene‐targeted mouse models to investigate the in vivo regulation of B‐cell survival and responsiveness. The control of BAFF‐dependent survival signals by the TRAF2‐ and TRAF3‐signaling proteins is discussed as is the potential involvement of these molecules in B‐lineage malignancies. We also outline the development and use of the SWHEL model for analyzing antigen‐specific B‐cell responses in vivo. This includes insights into the control of early decision‐making during T‐dependent B‐cell differentiation, the affinity maturation and plasma cell differentiation of germinal center B cells, and the identification of EBI2 as a key regulator of B‐cell migration and differentiation.