W. Steven Ward

Function of sperm chromatin structural elements in fertilization and development.

Understanding how DNA is packaged in the mammalian sperm cell has important implications for human infertility as well as for the cell biology. Recent advances in the study of mammalian sperm chromatin structure and function have altered our perception of this highly condensed, inert chromatin. Sperm DNA is packaged very tightly to protect the DNA during the transit that occurs before fertilization. However, this condensation cannot sacrifice chromosomal elements that are essential for the embryo to access the correct sequences of the paternal genome for proper initiation of the embryonic developmental program. The primary levels of the sperm chromatin structure can be divided into three main categories: the large majority of DNA is packaged by protamines, a smaller amount (2-15%) retains histone-bound chromatin and the DNA is attached to the nuclear matrix at roughly 50 kb intervals. Current data suggest that the latter two structural elements are transferred to the paternal pronucleus after fertilization where they have important functional roles. The nuclear matrix organization is essential for DNA replication, and the histone-bound chromatin identifies genes that are important for embryonic development. These data support the emerging view of the sperm genome as providing, in addition to the paternal DNA sequence, a structural framework that includes molecular regulatory factors that are required for proper embryonic development.

DNA loop domains in mammalian spermatozoa

The highly condensed and tightly packaged DNA of hamster spermatozoa was found to be organized into topologically constrained DNA loop domains attached at their bases to a nuclear matrix. The loop domains of the sperm nuclei differed from somatic cell loop domains from the same animal in two aspects. Sperm loop domains were 60% smaller than somatic cell loop domains, with an average DNA length of 46±7 kb in sperm as compared with 16±11 kb in brain. Secondly, unlike virtually all somatic cell DNA known which is negatively supercoiled, sperm DNA was devoid of detectable supercoiling. The presence of the loop domain structure in the highly condensed DNA of mammalian spermatozoa suggests that this motif is a fundamental aspect of eukaryotic DNA organization.

Ability of Hamster Spermatozoa to Digest Their Own DNA

Abstract Mammalian sperm chromatin is bound by protamines into highly condensed toroids with approximately 50 kilobases (kb) of DNA. It is also organized into loop domains of about the same size that are attached at their bases to the proteinaceous nuclear matrix. In this work, we test our model that each sperm DNA-loop domain is condensed into a single protamine toroid. Our model predicts that the protamine toroids are linked by chromatin that is more sensitive to nucleases than the DNA within the toroids. To test this model, we treated hamster sperm nuclei with DNase I and found that the sperm chromatin was digested into fragments with an average size of about 50 kb, by pulse-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). Surprisingly, we also found that spermatozoa treated with 0.25% Triton X-100 (TX) and 20 mM MgCl2 overnight resulted in the same type of degradation, suggesting that sperm nuclei have a mechanism for digesting their own DNA at the bases of the loop domains. We extracted the nuclei with 2 M NaCl and 10 mM dithiothreitol (DTT) to make nuclear halos. Nuclear matrices prepared from DNase I-treated spermatozoa had no DNA attached, suggesting that DNase I digested the DNA at the bases of the loop domains. TX-treated spermatozoa still had their entire DNA associated with the nuclear matrix, even though the DNA was digested into 50-kb fragments as revealed by PFGE. The data support our donut-loop model for sperm chromatin structure and suggest a functional role for this type of organization in that sperm can digest its own DNA at the sites of attachment to the nuclear matrix.

Expression of Foreign DNA Is Associated with Paternal Chromosome Degradation in Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection-Mediated Transgenesis in the Mouse

Abstract The efficiency of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI)-mediated transgenesis is often limited by poor embryo development. Because our previous work indicated that impairment of embryo development is frequently related to chromosomal abnormalities, we hypothesized that foreign DNA and/or conditions used to enhance integration of the DNA might induce chromosome damage. Therefore, we examined the chromosomes of mouse embryos produced by transgenesis with the EGFP gene. Spermatozoa were processed with three methods that cause membrane disruption: freeze-thawing, Triton X-100, or Triton X-100 followed by a sucrose wash. Membrane-disrupted spermatozoa were mixed with EGFP plasmids and injected into metaphase II oocytes. Three endpoints were evaluated: paternal chromosomes of the zygote, embryo capacity to develop in vitro, and expression of the transgene at the morula/blastocyst stage. In all pretreatments, we observed a significant decrease (approximately 2-fold) in the frequency of normal karyoplates when spermatozoa were incubated with exogenous DNA as compared with the treatment when no DNA was added. As predicted, embryo development was correlated with the integrity of the paternal chromosomes of the zygote. Searching for the possible mechanism of chromosome degradation, we used the ion chelators EGTA and EDTA and found that they neutralize the harmful effect of the transgene and stabilize the paternal chromosomes. In the presence of chelating agents, however, the number of embryos expressing EGFP produced with ICSI-mediated transgenesis decreased significantly. The results suggest that treatment of spermatozoa with exogenous DNA leads to paternal chromosome degradation in the zygote. Furthermore, the mechanisms of disruption of paternal chromosomes and the integration of foreign DNA may be closely related.

Combination of Dithiothreitol and Detergent Treatment of Spermatozoa Causes Paternal Chromosomal Damage

Abstract Treatment of spermatozoa with either the nonionic detergent Triton X-100 (TX) or dithiothreitol (DTT) has been suggested to confer enhanced success on intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) in mice and humans. Here, we attempted to use both reagents together, to our knowledge for the first time, and found that this caused severe chromosomal breaks in paternal pronuclei. We documented this effect further by treating mouse spermatozoa with several combinations of DTT with and without detergent. Spermatozoa were treated with vigorous pipetting to induce membrane disruption or with TX or the ionic detergent mixed alkyltrimethylammonium bromide (ATAB). Swim-up spermatozoa were used as controls. In each treatment, two samples were tested, with or without the addition of DTT during the treatment procedure. In all samples with DTT, protamine reduction was confirmed by the decondensation assay. Sperm nuclei obtained after different treatments were injected into oocytes for cytogenetic analysis, and paternal and maternal chromosomes of the zygote were visualized and examined. We found that the numbers of normal paternal karyoplates resulting from ICSI with spermatozoa treated with either DTT (87%, 153/176), TX (79%, 112/142), or ATAB (85%, 99/116) alone were similar to swim-up controls (92%, 103/112). However, only 22% (23/103) and 40% (59/149) of examined metaphases were scored as normal in TX + DTT or ATAB + DTT treatments, respectively. Spermatozoa in which the membranes were disrupted by vigorous pipetting in the presence of DTT had a slightly reduced frequency of normal chromosomes (61%, 64/104), whereas those without DTT were normal (79%, 125/159). However, this difference was not statistically significant. When spermatozoa were treated with TX + DTT in the presence of EGTA or a mixture of EGTA and EDTA, the frequency of normal chromosomes was 39% (45/114) and 47% (38/81), respectively, suggesting that endogenous sperm nucleases may play a role in chromosomal damage. Our results indicate that simultaneous treatment of spermatozoa with detergent and DTT induces extensive chromosomal breakage and, therefore, should not be attempted in ICSI.

Topoisomerase IIB and an Extracellular Nuclease Interact to Digest Sperm DNA in an Apoptotic-Like Manner

Abstract We previously demonstrated that mammalian spermatozoa contain a nuclease activity that cleaves DNA into loop-sized fragments. We show here that this activity is mediated by a nuclear matrix-associated topoisomerase IIB (TOP2B) interacting with an extracellular Mn2+/Ca2+-dependent nuclease. Together, these enzymes cleave all of the DNA into fragments of 50 kb, and this cleavage can be reversed by EDTA. If dithiothreitol is included, the nuclease digests the DNA, and if the protamines are removed the DNA is completely digested. A similar, TOP2B-mediated, chromatin fragmentation, which is reversible, followed by digestion of the DNA by an intracellular nuclease occurs in somatic cells during apoptosis. The extracellular location of the sperm nuclease made it possible to reconstitute the fragmentation activity in isolated spermatozoa, thus allowing us to identify two novel aspects of the mechanism. First, the fragmentation of all of the DNA to 50 kb by TOP2B required the addition of the extracellular nuclease or factor. Second, the subsequent, complete digestion of the DNA by the nuclease could be inhibited by etoposide, suggesting that the nuclease digestion requires TOP2B religation of the cleaved DNA. These data are the first demonstration of an active TOP2B in spermatozoa, suggesting this inert chromatin may be more active than previously thought. They also show that the unique chromatin structure of spermatozoa may provide an important model to study the regulated degradation of chromatin by TOP2B and associated nucleases.

A model for the function of sperm DNA degradation

In this review, we present our recent evidence suggesting, but not yet proving, that mammalian spermatozoa contain a mechanism by which they can digest their own DNA when exposed to a stressful environment. We discuss our recent data that demonstrate that when mammalian spermatozoa are treated in a variety of ways, the paternal chromosomes in the zygote, or the sperm DNA itself, are degraded into large, chromosome-sized fragments. These published data support the existence of nuclease activity in spermatozoa. We suggest that this nuclease activity is part of a mechanism the spermatozoon uses when it encounters a stressful environment to prevent fertilisation and to avoid the transmission of potentially damaged DNA to the embryo. We propose a model based on sperm chromatin structure by which this nuclease can digest the highly condensed sperm chromatin.

Specific organization of genes in relation to the sperm nuclear matrix

We have recently reported that mammalian sperm DNA, the most highly condensed and functionally inert eukaryotic DNA, is organized into DNA loop domains attached at their bases to a sperm nuclear matrix (Chromosoma, 98: 153, 1989). We report here the specific arrangement of genes within the sperm loop domains by measuring the proximity of six hamster genes to the sperm nuclear matrix. After restriction endonuclease treatment of sperm nuclear matrices, five genes were clearly not associated with the sperm nuclear matrix and only one, alpha A-crystallin, was within 2 Kb of the matrix. This suggests that sperm DNA is organized in a specific manner in relation to the sperm matrix.

Non-Genetic Contributions of the Sperm Nucleus to Embryonic Development

Recent data from several laboratories have provided evidence that the newly fertilized oocyte inherits epigenetic signals from the sperm chromatin that are required for proper embryonic development. For the purposes of this review, the term epigenetic is used to describe all types of molecular information that are transmitted from the sperm cell to the embryo. There are at least six different forms of epigenetic information that have already been established as being required for proper embryogenesis in mammals or for which there is evidence that it may do so. These are (i) DNA methylation; (ii) sperm-specific histones, (iii) other chromatin-associated proteins; (iv) the perinuclear theca proteins; (v) sperm-born RNAs and, the focus of this review; and (vi) the DNA loop domain organization by the sperm nuclear matrix. These epigenetic signals should be considered when designing protocols for the manipulation and cryopreservation of spermatozoa for assisted reproductive technology as necessary components for effective fertilization and subsequent embryo development.

Mouse Zygotes Respond to Severe Sperm DNA Damage by Delaying Paternal DNA Replication and Embryonic Development

Mouse zygotes do not activate apoptosis in response to DNA damage. We previously reported a unique form of inducible sperm DNA damage termed sperm chromatin fragmentation (SCF). SCF mirrors some aspects of somatic cell apoptosis in that the DNA degradation is mediated by reversible double strand breaks caused by topoisomerase 2B (TOP2B) followed by irreversible DNA degradation by a nuclease(s). Here, we created zygotes using spermatozoa induced to undergo SCF (SCF zygotes) and tested how they responded to moderate and severe paternal DNA damage during the first cell cycle. We found that the TUNEL assay was not sensitive enough to identify the breaks caused by SCF in zygotes in either case. However, paternal pronuclei in both groups stained positively for γH2AX, a marker for DNA damage, at 5 hrs after fertilization, just before DNA synthesis, while the maternal pronuclei were negative. We also found that both pronuclei in SCF zygotes with moderate DNA damage replicated normally, but paternal pronuclei in the SCF zygotes with severe DNA damage delayed the initiation of DNA replication by up to 12 hrs even though the maternal pronuclei had no discernable delay. Chromosomal analysis of both groups confirmed that the paternal DNA was degraded after S-phase while the maternal pronuclei formed normal chromosomes. The DNA replication delay caused a marked retardation in progression to the 2-cell stage, and a large portion of the embryos arrested at the G2/M border, suggesting that this is an important checkpoint in zygotic development. Those embryos that progressed through the G2/M border died at later stages and none developed to the blastocyst stage. Our data demonstrate that the zygote responds to sperm DNA damage through a non-apoptotic mechanism that acts by slowing paternal DNA replication and ultimately leads to arrest in embryonic development.