William M. Atkins

Chapter 11 Reconstitution of Membrane Proteins in Phospholipid Bilayer Nanodiscs

Self-assembled phospholipid bilayer Nanodiscs have become an important and versatile tool among model membrane systems to functionally reconstitute membrane proteins. Nanodiscs consist of lipid domains encased within an engineered derivative of apolipoprotein A-1 scaffold proteins, which can be tailored to yield homogeneous preparations of disks with different diameters, and with epitope tags for exploitation in various purification strategies. A critical aspect of the self-assembly of target membranes into Nanodiscs lies in the optimization of the lipid:protein ratio. Here we describe strategies for performing this optimization and provide examples for reconstituting bacteriorhodopsin as a trimer, rhodopsin, and functionally active P-glycoprotein. Together, these demonstrate the versatility of Nanodisc technology for preparing monodisperse samples of membrane proteins of wide-ranging structure.

Ligand Binding to Cytochrome P450 3A4 in Phospholipid Bilayer Nanodiscs THE EFFECT OF MODEL MEMBRANES

The membrane-bound protein cytochrome P450 3A4 (CYP3A4) is a major drug-metabolizing enzyme. Most studies of ligand binding by CYP3A4 are currently carried out in solution, in the absence of a model membrane. Therefore, there is little information concerning the membrane effects on CYP3A4 ligand binding behavior. Phospholipid bilayer Nanodiscs are a novel model membrane system derived from high density lipoprotein particles, whose stability, monodispersity, and consistency are ensured by their self-assembly. We explore the energetics of four ligands (6-(p-toluidino)-2-naphthalenesulfonic acid (TNS), α-naphthoflavone (ANF), miconazole, and bromocriptine) binding to CYP3A4 incorporated into Nanodiscs. Ligand binding to Nanodiscs was monitored by a combination of environment-sensitive ligand fluorescence and ligand-induced shifts in the fluorescence of tryptophan residues present in the scaffold proteins of Nanodiscs; binding to the CYP3A4 active site was monitored by ligand-induced shifts in the heme Soret band absorbance. The dissociation constants for binding to the active site in CYP3A4-Nanodiscs were 4.0 μm for TNS, 5.8 μm for ANF, 0.45 μm for miconazole, and 0.45 μm for bromocriptine. These values are for CYP3A4 incorporated into a lipid bilayer and are therefore presumably more biologically relevant that those measured using CYP3A4 in solution. In some cases, affinity measurements using CYP3A4 in Nanodiscs differ significantly from solution values. We also studied the equilibrium between ligand binding to CYP3A4 and to the membrane. TNS showed no marked preference for either environment; ANF preferentially bound to the membrane, and miconazole and bromocriptine preferentially bound to the CYP3A4 active site.

Impact of linker and conjugation chemistry on antigen binding, Fc receptor binding and thermal stability of model antibody-drug conjugates

Antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) with biotin as a model cargo tethered to IgG1 mAbs via different linkers and conjugation methods were prepared and tested for thermostability and ability to bind target antigen and Fc receptor. Most conjugates demonstrated decreased thermostability relative to unconjugated antibody, based on DSC, with carbohydrate and amine coupled ADCs showing the least effect compared with thiol coupled conjugates. A strong correlation between biotin-load and loss of stability is observed with thiol conjugation to one IgG scaffold, but the stability of a second IgG scaffold is relatively insensitive to biotin load. The same correlation for amine coupling was less significant. Binding of antibody to antigen and Fc receptor was investigated using surface plasmon resonance. None of the conjugates exhibited altered antigen affinity. Fc receptor FcγIIb (CD32b) interactions were investigated using captured antibody conjugate. Protein G and Protein A, known inhibitors of Fc receptor (FcR) binding to IgG, were also used to extend the analysis of the impact of conjugation on Fc receptor binding. H10NPEG4 was the only conjugate to show significant negative impact to FcR binding, which is likely due to higher biotin-load compared with the other ADCs. The ADC aHISNLC and aHISTPEG8 demonstrated some loss in affinity for FcR, but to much lower extent. The general insensitivity of target binding and effector function of the IgG1 platform to conjugation highlight their utility. The observed changes in thermostability require consideration for the choice of conjugation chemistry, depending on the system being pursued and particular application of the conjugate.

Interactions of glutathione transferases with 4-hydroxynonenal

Electrophilic products of lipid peroxidation are important contributors to the progression of several pathological states. The prototypical α,β–unsaturated aldehyde, 4-hydroxynonenal (HNE), triggers cellular events associated with oxidative stress, which can be curtailed by the glutathione-dependent elimination of HNE. The glutathione transferases (GSTs) are a major determinate of the intracellular concentration of HNE and can influence susceptibility to toxic effects, particularly when HNE and GST levels are altered in disease states. In this article, we provide a brief summary of the cellular effects of HNE, followed by a review of its GST-catalyzed detoxification, with an emphasis on the structural attributes that play an important role in the interactions with alpha-class GSTs. Some of the key determining characteristics that impart high alkenal activity reside in the unique C-terminal interactions of the GSTA4-4 enzyme. Studies encompassing both kinetic and structural analyses of related isoforms will be highlighted, with additional attention to stereochemical aspects that demonstrate the capacity of GSTA4-4 to detoxify both enantiomers of the biologically relevant racemic mixture while generating a select set of diastereomeric products with subsequent implications. A summary of the literature that examines the interplay between GSTs and HNE in model systems relevant to oxidative stress will also be discussed to demonstrate the magnitude of importance of GSTs in the overall detoxification scheme.

Functional Promiscuity Correlates with Conformational Heterogeneity in A-class Glutathione S-Transferases

The structurally related glutathione S-transferase isoforms GSTA1-1 and GSTA4-4 differ greatly in their relative catalytic promiscuity. GSTA1-1 is a highly promiscuous detoxification enzyme. In contrast, GSTA4-4 exhibits selectivity for congeners of the lipid peroxidation product 4-hydroxynonenal. The contribution of protein dynamics to promiscuity has not been studied. Therefore, hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (H/DX) and fluorescence lifetime distribution analysis were performed with glutathione S-transferases A1-1 and A4-4. Differences in local dynamics of the C-terminal helix were evident as expected on the basis of previous studies. However, H/DX demonstrated significantly greater solvent accessibility throughout most of the GSTA1-1 sequence compared with GSTA4-4. A Phe-111/Tyr-217 aromatic-aromatic interaction in A4-4, which is not present in A1-1, was hypothesized to increase core packing. “Swap” mutants that eliminate this interaction from A4-4 or incorporate it into A1-1 yield H/DX behavior that is intermediate between the wild type templates. In addition, the single Trp-21 residue of each isoform was exploited to probe the conformational heterogeneity at the intrasubunit domain-domain interface. Excited state fluorescence lifetime distribution analysis indicates that this core residue is more conformationally heterogeneous in GSTA1-1 than in GSTA4-4, and this correlates with greater stability toward urea denaturation for GSTA4-4. The fluorescence distribution and urea sensitivity of the mutant proteins were intermediate between the wild type templates. The results suggest that the differences in protein dynamics of these homologs are global. The results suggest also the possible importance of extensive conformational plasticity to achieve high levels of functional promiscuity, possibly at the cost of stability.

1.3-Å Resolution structure of human glutathione S-transferase with S-hexyl glutathione bound reveals possible extended ligandin binding site

Cytosolic glutathione S‐transferases (GSTs) play a critical role in xenobiotic binding and metabolism, as well as in modulation of oxidative stress. Here, the high‐resolution X‐ray crystal structures of homodimeric human GSTA1‐1 in the apo form and in complex with S‐hexyl glutathione (two data sets) are reported at 1.8, 1.5, and 1.3Å respectively. At this level of resolution, distinct conformations of the alkyl chain of S‐hexyl glutathione are observed, reflecting the nonspecific nature of the hydrophobic substrate binding site (H‐site). Also, an extensive network of ordered water, including 75 discrete solvent molecules, traverses the open subunit–subunit interface and connects the glutathione binding sites in each subunit. In the highest‐resolution structure, three glycerol moieties lie within this network and directly connect the amino termini of the glutathione molecules. A search for ligand binding sites with the docking program Molecular Operating Environment identified the ordered water network binding site, lined mainly with hydrophobic residues, suggesting an extended ligand binding surface for nonsubstrate ligands, the so‐called ligandin site. Finally, detailed comparison of the structures reported here with previously published X‐ray structures reveal a possible reaction coordinate for ligand‐dependent conformational changes in the active site and the C‐terminus. Proteins 2002;48:618–627.

Interactions of Cytochrome P450s with their Ligands

Cytochrome P450s (CYPs) are heme-containing monooxygenases that contribute to an enormous range of enzymatic function including biosynthetic and detoxification roles. This review summarizes recent studies concerning interactions of CYPs with ligands including substrates, inhibitors, and diatomic heme-ligating molecules. These studies highlight the complexity in the relationship between the heme spin state and active site occupancy, the roles of water in directing protein-ligand and ligand-heme interactions, and the details of interactions between heme and gaseous diatomic CYP ligands. Both kinetic and thermodynamic aspects of ligand binding are considered.

Conformational analysis of human ATP-binding cassette transporter (ABCB1) in lipid nanodiscs and inhibition by the antibodies MRK16 and UIC2

Background: P-glycoprotein plays a role in drug resistance and drug interactions. Results: Surface plasmon resonance with P-glycoprotein in lipid nanodiscs indicates that inhibitory antibodies uncouple the ATP hydrolysis of P-gp from its transport function. Conclusion: Inhibitory antibodies do not prevent P-gp flux through the catalytic cycle, but rather block drug efflux without inhibiting ATP hydrolysis. Significance: The results clarify the mechanism of inhibitory antibodies to P-gp. The human ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter, P-glycoprotein (P-gp; ABCB1), mediates the ATP-dependent efflux of a variety of drugs. As a result, P-gp plays a critical role in tumor cell drug resistance and the pharmacokinetic properties of most drugs. P-gp exhibits extraordinary substrate and inhibitor promiscuity, resulting in a wide range of possible drug-drug interactions. Inhibitory antibodies have long been considered as a possible strategy to modulate P-gp-dependent cancer cell drug resistance, and it is widely suggested that the antibodies MRK16 and UIC2 inhibit P-gp by capturing a single isoform and preventing flux through the catalytic cycle. Although the crystal structures of many bacterial whole transporters, as well as isolated nucleotide-binding domains, have been solved, high resolution structural data for mammalian ABC transporters are currently lacking. It has been extremely difficult to determine the detailed mechanism of transport of P-gp, in part because it is difficult to obtain purified protein in well defined lipid systems. Here we exploit surface plasmon resonance (SPR) to probe conformational changes associated with these intermediate states for P-gp in lipid bilayer nanodiscs. The results indicate that P-gp in nanodiscs undergoes functionally relevant ligand-dependent conformational changes and that previously described inhibitory antibodies bind to multiple nucleotide-bound states but not the ADP-VO4-trapped state, which mimics the post-hydrolysis state. The results also suggest that the substrate drug vinblastine is released at stages that precede or follow the post-hydrolysis ADP-PO4·P-gp complex.

Implications of the allosteric kinetics of cytochrome P450s.

Drug metabolites can uniquely contribute to therapeutic efficacy, toxicity and drug-drug interactions. Therefore, the rates of formation and clearance of each metabolite are crucially important parameters in the net therapeutic profile of new drugs. However, the recent appreciation for the importance of drug metabolism has made it apparent that the understanding of the fundamental kinetic and biophysical properties of the enzymes that are responsible for catalyzing these reactions, the cytochrome P450s, is incomplete. The need to fully comprehend the complex allosteric behavior of these enzymes has fostered increased scrutiny of cytochrome P450s, which has subsequently resulted in major changes in the way that these enzymes are perceived at the molecular level.

Substrate specificity combined with stereopromiscuity in glutathione transferase A4-4-dependent metabolism of 4-hydroxynonenal.

Conjugation to glutathione (GSH) by glutathione transferase A4-4 (GSTA4-4) is a major route of elimination for the lipid peroxidation product 4-hydroxynonenal (HNE), a toxic compound that contributes to numerous diseases. Both enantiomers of HNE are presumed to be toxic, and GSTA4-4 has negligible stereoselectivity toward them, despite its high catalytic chemospecificity for alkenals. In contrast to the highly flexible, and substrate promiscuous, GSTA1-1 isoform that has poor catalytic efficiency with HNE, GSTA4-4 has been postulated to be a rigid template that is preorganized for HNE metabolism. However, the combination of high substrate chemoselectivity and low substrate stereoselectivity is intriguing. The mechanism by which GSTA4-4 achieves this combination is important, because it must metabolize both enantiomers of HNE to efficiently detoxify the biologically formed mixture. The crystal structures of GSTA4-4 and an engineered variant of GSTA1-1 with high catalytic efficiency toward HNE, cocrystallized with a GSH-HNE conjugate analogue, demonstrate that GSTA4-4 undergoes no enantiospecific induced fit; instead, the active site residue Arg15 is ideally located to interact with the 4-hydroxyl group of either HNE enantiomer. The results reveal an evolutionary strategy for achieving biologically useful stereopromiscuity toward a toxic racemate, concomitant with high catalytic efficiency and substrate specificity toward an endogenously formed toxin.