Xiao Lan Xu

D-3-Phosphoglycerate Dehydrogenase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis Is a Link between the Escherichia coli and Mammalian Enzymes

d-3-Phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase (PGDH) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis has been isolated to homogeneity and displays an unusual relationship to the Escherichia coli and mammalian enzymes. In almost all aspects investigated, the M. tuberculosis enzyme shares the characteristics of the mammalian PGDHs. These include an extended C-terminal motif, substrate inhibition kinetics, dependence of activity levels and stability on ionic strength, and the inability to utilize α-ketoglutarate as a substrate. The unique property that the M. tuberculosis enzyme shares with E. coli PGDH that it is very sensitive to inhibition by l-serine, with an I0.5 = 30 μm. The mammalian enzymes are not inhibited by l-serine. In addition, the cooperativity of serine inhibition appears to be modulated by chloride ion, becoming positively cooperative in its presence. This is modulated by the gain of cooperativity in serine binding for the first two effector sites. The basis for the chloride modulation of cooperativity is not known, but the sensitivity to serine inhibition can be explained in terms of certain amino acid residues in critical areas of the structures. The differential sensitivity to serine inhibition by M. tuberculosis and human PGDH may open up interesting possibilities in the treatment of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis.

The contribution of adjacent subunits to the active sites of D-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase.

d-3-Phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase (PGDH) from Escherichia coli is allosterically inhibited by l-serine, the end product of its metabolic pathway. Previous results have shown that inhibition by serine has a large effect on V max and only a small or negligible effect on K m . PGDH is thus classified as a V-type allosteric enzyme. In this study, the active site of PGDH has been studied by site-directed mutagenesis to assess the role of certain residues in substrate binding and catalysis. These consist of a group of cationic residues (Arg-240, Arg-60, Arg-62, Lys-39, and Lys-141′) that potentially form an electrostatic environment for the binding of the negatively charged substrate, as well as the only tryptophan residue found in PGDH and which fits into a hydrophobic pocket immediately adjacent to the active site histidine residue. Interestingly, Trp-139′ and Lys-141′ are part of the polypeptide chain of the subunit that is adjacent to the active site. The results of mutating these residues show that Arg-240, Arg-60, Arg-62, and Lys-141′ play distinct roles in the binding of the substrate to the active site. Mutants of Trp-139′ show that this residue may play a role in stabilizing the catalytic center of the enzyme. Furthermore, these mutants appear to have a significant effect on the cooperativity of serine inhibition and suggest a possible role for Trp-139′ in the cooperative interactions between subunits.

A novel mechanism for substrate inhibition in Mycobacterium tuberculosis D-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase

Mycobacterium tuberculosis d-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase undergoes significant inhibition of activity with increasing concentrations of its substrate, hydroxypyruvic acid phosphate. The enzyme also displays an unusual dual pH optimum. A significant decrease in the Ki for substrate inhibition at pH values corresponding to the valley between these optima is responsible for this phenomena. The change in Ki has an average pK of ∼5.8 and involves two functional groups that are protonated and two functional groups that are unprotonated for optimal substrate inhibition to occur. Mutagenesis of positively charged amino acid residues at a putative anion binding site previously revealed by the x-ray structure, produces significant changes in the pH-dependent profile of substrate inhibition. Several single residue mutations eliminate the dual pH optima by reducing substrate inhibition between pH 5 and 7 and a triple mutation was identified that eliminates the substrate inhibition altogether. The mutagenesis data support the conclusion that the anion binding site represents a new allosteric site for the control of enzyme activity and functions in a novel mechanism for substrate inhibition.

Amino Acid Residue Mutations Uncouple Cooperative Effects inEscherichia coli d-3-Phosphoglycerate Dehydrogenase

d-3-Phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase from Escherichia coli contains two Gly-Gly sequences that occur at junctions between domains. A previous study (Grant, G. A., Xu, X. L., and Hu, Z. (2000)Biochemistry 39, 7316–7319) determined that the Gly-Gly sequence at the junction between the regulatory and substrate binding domain functions as a hinge between the domains. Mutations in this area significantly decrease the ability of serine to inhibit activity but have little effect on the K m andk cat. Conversely, the present study shows that mutations to the Gly-Gly sequence at the junction of the substrate and nucleotide binding domains, which form the active site cleft, have a significant effect on the k cat of the enzyme without substantially altering the enzymes sensitivity to serine. In addition, mutation of Gly-294, but not Gly-295, has a profound effect on the cooperativity of serine inhibition. Interestingly, even though cooperativity of inhibition can be reduced significantly, there is little apparent effect on the cooperativity of serine binding itself. An additional mutant, G336V,G337V, also reduces the cooperativity of inhibition, but in this case serine binding also is reduced to the point at which it cannot be measured by equilibrium dialysis. The double mutant G294V,G336V demonstrates that strain imposed by mutation at one hinge can be relieved partially by mutation at the other hinge, demonstrating linkage between the two hinge regions. These data show that the two cooperative processes, serine binding and catalytic inhibition, can be uncoupled. Consideration of the allowable torsional angles for the side chains introduced by the mutations yields a range of values for these angles that the glycine residues likely occupy in the native enzyme. A comparison of these values with the torsional angles found for the inhibited enzyme from crystal coordinates provides potential beginning and ending orientations for the transition from active to inhibited enzyme, which will allow modeling of the dynamics of domain movement.

PROBING THE REGULATORY DOMAIN INTERFACE OF D-3-PHOSPHOGLYCERATE DEHYDROGENASE WITH ENGINEERED TRYPTOPHAN RESIDUES

d-3-Phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase from Escherichia coli is a homotetrameric enzyme which is allosterically regulated by the end product of its pathway, l-serine. The enzyme binds 4 l-serine molecules at two interfaces formed by the noncovalent association of the regulatory domains. The two domains that comprise each interface are related by an approximately 180° axis of symmetry, and two serine molecules bind at each interface by forming a hydrogen bond network between the domains. A model has been proposed that suggests that serine functions by drawing adjacent domains together and that this in turn translates a conformational change to the active site. A tryptophan residue has been engineered into the helices flanking the regulatory interfaces that displays significant quenching in response to serine binding. Residues on the adjacent subunit appear to be primarily responsible for the tryptophan quenching and thus support the hypothesis that serine binding leads to an increase in the proximity between residues on neighboring subunits. Serine binding studies show that this quenching, as well as inhibition of enzymatic activity, are essentially complete when only two of the four serine binding sites are occupied. The requirement for only one serine per interface is consistent with the notion that the interface is formed by relatively rigid domains and that hydrogen bonding at only a single site is all that is required to substantially close the interface. The fluorescence quenching in response to l-serine binding generally correlates with enzymatic inhibition, but there appears to be a slight lag in inhibition relative to quenching at low serine concentrations. The observed fluorescence quenching of residues in the regulatory domains of d-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase provide the first direct evidence for a conformational change in response to effector binding and provide a means to monitor the first step in the allosteric mechanism.

Hybrid tetramers reveal elements of cooperativity in Escherichia coli D-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase.

d-3-Phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase from Escherichia coli is a tetramer of identical subunits that is inhibited when l-serine binds at allosteric sites between subunits. Co-expression of two genes, the native gene containing a charge difference mutation and a gene containing a mutation that eliminates serine binding, produces hybrid tetramers that can be separated by ion exchange chromatography. Activity in the hybrid tetramer with only a single intact serine binding site is inhibited by ∼58% with a Hill coefficient of 1. Thus, interaction at a single regulatory domain interface does not, in itself, lead to the positive cooperativity of inhibition manifest in the native enzyme. Tetramers with only two intact serine binding sites purify as a mixture that displays a maximum inhibition level that is less than that of native enzyme, suggesting the presence of a population of tetramers that are unable to be fully inhibited. Differential analysis of this mixture supports the conclusion that it contains two forms of the tetramer. One form contains two intact serine binding sites at the same interface and is not fully inhibitable. The second form is a fully inhibitable population that has one serine binding site at each interface. Overall, the hybrid tetramers show that the positive cooperativity observed for serine binding is mediated across the nucleotide binding domain interface, and the negative cooperativity is mediated across the regulatory domain interface. That is, they reveal a pattern in which the binding of serine at one interface leads to negative cooperativity of binding of a subsequent serine at the same interface and positive cooperativity of binding of a subsequent serine to the opposite interface. This trend is propagated to subsequent binding sites in the tetramer such that the negative cooperativity that is originally manifest at one interface is decreased by subsequent binding of ligand at the opposite interface.

Cofactor Binding to Escherichia coli d-3-Phosphoglycerate Dehydrogenase Induces Multiple Conformations Which Alter Effector Binding

The inhibition of Escherichia coli d-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase by l-serine is positively cooperative with a Hill coefficient of ∼2, whereas the binding of the inhibitor, l-serine, to the apoenzyme displays positive cooperativity in the binding of the first two serine molecules and negative cooperativity in the binding of the last two serine molecules. An earlier report demonstrated that the presence of phosphate appeared to lessen the degree of both the positive and negative cooperativity, but the cause of this effect was unknown. This study demonstrates that the presence of intrinsically bound NADH was responsible to a substantial degree for this effect. In addition, this study also provides evidence for negative cooperativity in NADH binding and for at least two NADH-induced conformational forms of the enzyme that bind the inhibitor in the physiological range. Successive binding of NADH to the enzyme resulted in an increase in the affinity for the first inhibitor ligand bound and a lessening of both the positive and negative cooperativity of inhibitor binding as compared with that seen in the absence of NADH. This effect was specific for NADH and was not observed in the presence of NAD+ or the substrate α-ketoglutarate. Conversely, the binding of l-serine did not have a significant effect on the stoichiometry of NADH binding, consistent with it being a V-type allosteric system. Thus, cofactor-related conditions were found in equilibrium binding experiments that significantly altered the cooperativity of inhibitor binding. Since the result of inhibitor binding is a reduction in the catalytic activity, the binding of inhibitor to these NADH-induced conformers must also induce additional conformations that lead to differential inhibition of catalytic activity.

Kinetic, mutagenic, and structural homology analysis of l-serine dehydratase from Legionella pneumophila

A structural database search has revealed that the same fold found in the allosteric substrate binding (ASB) domain of Mycobacterium tuberculosis D-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase (PGDH) is found in l-serine dehydratase from Legionella pneumophila. The M. tuberculosis PGDH ASB domain functions in the control of catalytic activity. Bacterial l-serine dehydratases are 4Fe-4S proteins that convert l-serine to pyruvate and ammonia. Sequence homology reveals two types depending on whether their α and β domains are on the same (Type 2) or separate (Type 1) polypeptides. The α domains contain the catalytic iron-sulfur center while the β domains do not yet have a described function, but the structural homology with PGDH suggests a regulatory role. Type 1 β domains also contain additional sequence homologous to PGDH ACT domains. A continuous assay for l-serine dehydratase is used to demonstrate homotropic cooperativity, a broad pH range, and essential irreversibility. Product inhibition analysis reveals a Uni-Bi ordered mechanism with ammonia dissociating before pyruvate. l-Threonine is a poor substrate and l-cysteine and d-serine are competitive inhibitors with K(i) values that differ by almost 10-fold from those reported for Escherichia colil-serine dehydratase. Mutagenesis identifies the three cysteine residues at the active site that anchor the iron-sulfur complex.

Role of the anion-binding site in catalysis and regulation of Mycobacterium tuberculosis D-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase.

D-3-Phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis displays substantial substrate inhibition in the direction of NADH oxidation by its physiological substrate, hydroxypyruvic acid phosphate (HPAP). Previous investigations showed that plots of substrate concentration versus activity derived from steady state assays could be fit with the equation for complete uncompetitive inhibition and that the mechanism may be allosteric. This investigation uses a simulation of transient kinetic data to demonstrate that the mechanism is consistent with the interaction of substrate at a second site called the anion-binding site. While addition of substrate at the active site is ordered, with HPAP binding before NADH, NADH can compete with the substrate for binding to the allosteric site and thereby eliminate the substrate inhibition. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer analysis of mutants with specific tryptophan residues converted to phenylalanine residues demonstrates that the main interaction of NADH with the enzyme, in the absence of substrate, is at the allosteric anion-binding site. This is further confirmed by mutations of basic residues at the anion-binding site which also demonstrates that these residues are necessary for inhibition by l-serine when it binds to the regulatory domain. This may indicate that a ligand must be bound to the anion-binding site for l-serine inhibition, providing a potential mechanism for low levels of activity in the presence of high levels of inhibitor.

The Effect of Hinge Mutations on Effector Binding and Domain Rotation in Escherichia coli D-3-Phosphoglycerate Dehydrogenase.

d-3-Phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.95) from Escherichia coli contains two Gly-Gly sequences that have been shown previously to have the characteristics of hinge regions. One of these, Gly336-Gly337, is found in the loop between the substrate binding domain and the regulatory domain. Changing these glycine residues to valine affected the sensitivity of the enzyme to inhibition by l-serine but not the extent of inhibition. The decrease in sensitivity was caused primarily by a decrease in the affinity of the enzyme for l-serine. These mutations also affected the domain rotation of the subunits in response to l-serine binding. A major conclusion of this study was that it defines a minimal limit on the necessary conformational changes leading to inhibition of enzyme activity. That is, some of the conformational differences seen in the native enzyme upon l-serine binding are not critical for inhibition, whereas others are maintained and may play important roles in inhibition and cooperativity. The structure of G336V demonstrates that the minimal effect of l-serine binding leading to inhibition of enzyme activity requires a domain rotation of approximately only 6° in just two of the four subunits of the enzyme that are oriented diagonally across from each other in the tetramer. Moreover the structures show that both pairs of Asn190 to Asn190 hydrogen bonds across the subunit interfaces are necessary for activity. These observations are consistent with the half-the-sites activity, flip-flop mechanism proposed for this and other similar enzymes and suggest that the Asn190 hydrogen bonds may function in the conformational transition between alternate half-the-site active forms of the enzyme.