Edward P. Clark

The role of thiols in cellular response to radiation and drugs.

Cellular nonprotein thiols (NPSH) consist of glutathione (GSH) and other low molecular weight species such as cysteine, cysteamine, and coenzyme A. GSH is usually less than the total cellular NPSH, and with thiol reactive agents, such as diethyl maleate (DEM), its rate of depletion is in part dependent upon the cellular capacity for its resynthesis. If resynthesis is blocked by buthionine-S,R-sulfoximine(BSO), the NPSH, including GSH, is depleted more rapidly, Cellular thiol depletion by diamide, N-ethylmaleimide, and BSO may render oxygenated cells more sensitive to radiation. These cells may or may not show a reduction in the oxygen enhancement ratio (OER). Human A549 lung carcinoma cells depleted of their NPSH either by prolonged culture or by BSO treatment do not show a reduced OER but do show increased aerobic responses to radiation. Some nitroheterocyclic radiosensitizing drugs also deplete cellular thiols under aerobic conditions. Such reactivity may be the reason that they show anomalous radiation sensitization (i.e., better than predicted on the basis of electron affinity). Other nitrocompounds, such as misonidazole, are activated under hypoxic conditions to radical intermediates. When cellular thiols are depleted peroxide is formed. Under hypoxic conditions thiols are depleted because metabolically reduced intermediates react with GSH instead of oxygen. Thiol depletion, under hypoxic conditions, may be the reason that misonidazole and other nitrocompounds show an extra enhancement ratio with hypoxic cells. Thiol depletion by DEM or BSO alters the radiation response of hypoxic cells to misonidazole. In conclusion, we propose an altered thiol model which includes a mechanism for thiol involvement in the aerobic radiation response of cells. This mechanism involves both thiol-linked hydrogen donation to oxygen radical adducts to produce hydroperoxides followed by a GSH peroxidase-catalyzed reduction of the hydroperoxides to intermediates entering into metabolic pathways to produce the original molecule.

Effects of antioxidants on oxidant-induced sister chromatid exchange formation.

Stimulated human phagocytes produce sister chromatid exchanges in cultured mammalian cells by a mechanism involving oxygen metabolites. Experiments were designed to determine whether antioxidants inhibit this process. Superoxide dismutase, catalase, and hydroxyl radical scavengers (benzoate, mannitol) protected target Chinese hamster ovary cells from phagocyte-induced sister chromatid exchanges, implicating the involvement of hydroxyl radicals in this chromosomal damage. N-acetylcysteine and beta-carotene were also protective. alpha-Tocopherol (greater than 5 microM) protected target cells exposed to phagocytes but not to enzymatically generated oxidants when the vitamin was added just before the source of oxygen radicals, suggesting, as reported by others, that the principal action of tocopherol in this setting was to inhibit the release of oxidants from phagocytes. On the other hand, cultivation of target cells with supplemental tocopherol protected them from the toxic effects of the enzymatic oxidant-producing system, indicating a role for membrane-associated free radicals in the mechanism of sister chromatid exchange induction. Low concentrations of sodium selenite (0.1-1.0 microM) protected the target cells. However, higher concentrations (10 microM) of selenite had no effect on oxidant-induced sister chromatid exchange formation, and 0.1 mM selenite increased the number of exchanges. Sodium selenite concentrations of 0.1 mM also decreased the intracellular glutathione concentration of target cells during an oxidant stress, and reducing target cell glutathione concentrations with buthionine sulfoximine increased their sensitivity to oxygen-related chromosomal damage. Therefore, the potentiation of oxygen radical-induced chromosomal damage observed with high concentrations of selenite may result from a decrease in the thiol antioxidant defense systems within the cell. The findings suggest that the hydroxyl radical has an important role in the production of phagocyte-induced cytogenetic injury, membrane-derived intermediates may be involved, depletion of intracellular glutathione renders cells more susceptible to this injury, and supplementation of target cells with antioxidants can protect them from oxygen radical-generated chromosomal injury.

Advances in Radioprotection through the Use of Combined Agent Regimens

The most effective radioprotective agents exhibit toxicities that can limit their usefulness. It may be possible to use combinations of agents with different radioprotective mechanisms of action at less toxic doses, or to reduce the toxicity of the major protective compound by adding another agent. With regard to the latter possibility, improved radioprotection and reduced lethal toxicity of the phosphorothioate WR-2721 was observed when it was administered in combination with metals (selenium, zinc or copper). The known mechanisms of action of potential radioprotective agents and varying effects of different doses and times of administration in relation to radiation exposure must be considered when using combined-agent regimens. A number of receptor-mediated protectors and other biological compounds, including endotoxin, eicosanoids and cytokines, have at least an additive effect when administered with thiol protectors. Eicosanoids and other bioactive lipids must be administered before radiation exposure, whereas some immunomodulators have activity when administered either before or after radiation exposure. For example, the cytokine interleukin-1 administered simultaneously with WR-2721 before irradiation or after irradiation enhances the radioprotective efficacy of WR-2721. The most effective single agents or combinations of protectors result in a decrement in locomotor activity, an index of behavioral toxicity. Recent evidence indicates that administration of the CNS stimulant caffeine mitigates the behavioral toxicity of an effective radioprotective dose of the phosphorothioate WR-3689 without altering its radioprotective efficacy. These examples indicate that the use of combinations of agents is a promising approach for maximizing radioprotection with minimal adverse effects.

Biochemistry of reduction of nitro heterocycles.

Misonidazole is a metabolically active drug. Its addition to cells causes an immediate alteration in cellular electron transfer pathways. Under aerobic conditions the metabolic alterations can result in futile cycling with electron transfer to oxygen and production of peroxide. Thiol levels are extremely important in protecting the cell against the peroxide formation and potentially hazardous conditions for hydroxyl radical production. Nevertheless such electron shunting out of cellular metabolism will result in alterations in pentose cycle, glycolysis and cellular capacity to reduce metabolites to essential intermediates needed in DNA metabolism (i.e. deoxyribonucleotides). Glutathione must be depleted to very low levels before toxic effects of misonidazole and other nitro compounds are manifested in cell death via peroxidative damage. Under hypoxic conditions misonidazole also diverts the pentose cycle via its own reduction; however, unlike the aerobic conditions, there are a number of reductive intermediates produced that react with non-protein thiols such as GSH as well as protein thiols. The reaction with protein thiols results in the inhibition of glycolysis and other as yet undetermined enzyme systems. The consequences of the hypoxic pretreatment of cells with nitro compounds are increased vulnerability to radiation and chemotherapeutic drugs such as L-PAM, cis-platinum and bleomycin. The role that altered enzyme activity has in the cellular response to misonidazole and chemotherapeutic agents remains to be determined. It is also clear that the GSH depleted state not only makes cells more vulnerable to oxidative stress but also to hypoxic intermediates produced by the reduction of misonidazole beyond the one electron stage. The relevancy of the present work to the proposed use of thiol depletion in vivo to enhance the radiation or chemotherapeutic response of tumor tissue lies with the following considerations. Apparently, spontaneous peroxidative damage to normal tissue such as liver can occur with GSH depletion to 10-20% of control and with other normal tissue when GSH reaches 50% of control. This situation can obviously become more critical if peroxide producing drugs are administered. The only advantage to such combined drug treatments would lie in the possibility that tumors vary in their catalase and peroxidase activity and consequently may be more vulnerable to oxidative stress (cf. review by Meister. Our tumor model, the A549 human lung carcinoma cell in vitro, appears to be an exception because it has catalase, peroxidase and a high content of GSH.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Nonprotein Thiols and the Radiation Response of A549 Human Lung Carcinoma Cells

Glutathione (GSH)-depletion by buthionine sulphoximine (BSO) altered both the aerobic and anaerobic radiation response of A549 human lung cancer cells grown in vitro. The oxygen enhancement ratio (o.e.r) was increased slightly from 3.0-3.3. The lack of an effect of GSH-depletion on o.e.r. reduction, provides a system whereby the mechanism of action of the thiol reactive reagent diethylmaleate (DEM) can be investigated. Pretreatment of cells with DEM, under non-toxic concentrations, removed 13 per cent of the intracellular NPSH and resulted in an o.e.r. of 2. When BSO followed by DEM was used, so that both GSH and NPSH were reduced to zero, an o.e.r. of 1.5 was obtained. Cells treated with 1 mM BSO for 24 hours contained 10 per cent NPSH and no GSH. When these cells were exposed to 0.5 or 1 mM DEM briefly, during irradiation, the o.e.r. was 2.4 and 1.7 respectively. In some cases altered o.e.r.s occurred in combination with increased aerobic responses. This was especially true for aerobic irradiations of BSO-treated cells in the presence or absence of DEM. However, the increased aerobic response was offset by a more dramatic increase in the hypoxic response. These results indicate (a) that GSH plays a significant role in aerobic radiation response but is not a principal factor in o.e.r.-reduction, and (b) that reduction of the o.e.r. by DEM is not due primarily to GSH-removal. The preferential radiosensitization of hypoxic cells by DEM may involve reactions of this compound with NPSH or protein SH, or may be related to the ability of DEM to mimic oxygen as a hypoxic cell radiosensitizer.

Glutathione depletion, radiosensitization, and misonidazole potentiation in hypoxic Chinese hamster ovary cells by buthionine sulfoximine

Buthionine sulfoximine (BSO) inhibits the synthesis of glutathione (GSH), the major nonprotein sulfhydryl (NPSH) present in most mammalian cells. BSO concentrations from 1 microM to 0.1 mM reduced intracellular GSH at different rates, while BSO greater than or equal to 0.1 mM (i.e., 0.1 to 2.0 mM), resulting in inhibitor-enzyme saturation, depleted GSH to less than 10% of control within 10 hr at about equal rates. BSO exposures used in these experiments were not cytotoxic with the one exception that 2.0 mM BSO/24 hr reduced cell viability to approximately 50%. However, alterations in either the cell doubling time(s) or the cell age density distribution(s) were not observed with the BSO exposures used to determine its radiosensitizing effect. BSO significantly radiosensitized (ER = 1.41 with 0.1 mM BSO/24 hr) hypoxic, but not aerobic, CHO cells when the GSH and NPSH concentrations were reduced to less than 10 and 20% of control, respectively, and maximum radiosensitivity was even achieved with microM concentrations of BSO (ER = 1.38 with 10 microM BSO/24 hr). Furthermore, BSO exposure (0.1 mM BSO/24 hr) also enhanced the radiosensitizing effect of various concentrations of misonidazole on hypoxic CHO cells.

Increased radiation resistance in transformed and nontransformed cells with elevated ras proto-oncogene expression

The cellular Ha-ras oncogene, activated by missense mutations, has been implicated in intrinsic resistance to ionizing radiation. This study shows that the overexpression of the unmutated gene (proto-oncogene) may also be involved in how the cells respond to radiation. The experimental system consisted of mouse NIH 3T3-derived cell lines which carry multiple copies of a transcriptionally activated human c-Ha-ras proto-oncogene. Both tumorigenic (RS485) and revertant nontumorigenic subclones (PR4 and 4C3) which have high levels of ras expression exhibited a marked increase in radioresistance as measured by D0 compared to control NIH 3T3 cells. Other nontransformed cells with elevated levels of ras (phenotypically revertant line 4C8-A10) also had a significantly increased resistance to radiation, further indicating an association between ras and radioresistance. The increased radioresistance of the RS485 and phenotypic revertants could not be explained by a differential expression of the myc or metallothionein I genes or by variations in cell cycle. The correlation between increased ras proto-oncogene expression and radioresistance suggests that the ras encoded p21, a plasma membrane protein, may participate in the cellular responses to ionizing radiation.

The role of glutathione in the aerobic radioresponse. I. Sensitization and recovery in the absence of intracellular glutathione.

The effect of changes in both the intracellular glutathione (GSH) concentration and the concentration of extracellular reducing equivalents on the aerobic radiosensitization was studied in three cell lines: CHO-10B4, V79, and A549. Intracellular GSH was metabolically depleted after the inhibition of GSH synthesis by buthionine sulfoximine (BSO), while the extracellular environment was controlled through the replacement of growth medium with a thiol-free salt solution and in some experiments by the exogenous addition of either GSH or GSSG. Each of the cell lines examined exhibited an enhanced aerobic radioresponse when the intracellular GSH was extensively depleted (GSH less than 1 nmol GSH/10(6) cells after 1.0 mM BSO/24 h treatment) and the complexity of the extracellular milieu decreased. Although the addition of oxidized glutathione (5 mM GSSG/30 min) to cells prior to irradiation was without effect, much or all of the induced radiosensitivity was overcome by the addition of reduced glutathione (5 mM GSH/15 min). However, the observation that the exogenous GSH addition restores the control radioresponse without increasing the intracellular GSH concentration was entirely unexpected. These results suggest that a number of factors exert an influence on the extent of GSH depletion and determine the extent of aerobic radiosensitization. Furthermore, the interaction of exogenous GSH with--but without penetrating--the cell membrane is sufficient to result in radiorecovery.

The effect of L-buthionine sulfoximine on the aerobic radiation response of A549 human lung carcinoma cells

Our data show that A549 cells are increasingly radiosensitive with prolonged exposure to L-BSO. The resulting glutathione and protein thiol depleted cells show both loss of shoulder and slope modification. Furthermore, there is an increase in single strand DNA breaks and irrepairable cross-linking. The aerobic radiation damage in the thiol depleted state appears to be different from that obtained with hypoxic cells. Any postulated role for GSH in reducing or preventing peroxidative radiation damage must also include protection against single strand DNA breaks as well as involvement in repairing DNA-protein cross-links. The latter effect may be related to decreased protein thiol content as reflected in a decreased enzyme capacity to repair DNA damage.

Effect of Dimethyl Fumarate on the Radiation Sensitivity of Mammalian Cells in Vitro

Dimethylfumarate (DMF) depletes intracellular glutathione (GSH) by covalent bond formation in a reaction which may be mediated by GSH-S-transferase. In Chinese hamster ovary cells this depletion is rapid; e.g., 0.5 mM DMF depletes GSH to less than 10% of control in 5 min at room temperature. DMF is a very effective hypoxic cell radiosensitizer, with an enhancement ratio (ER) of about 3 obtained by a 5-min exposure of cells at room temperature to 5 mM DMF, without significant toxicity. At this same concentration of drug, there is a small enhancement of aerobic cells (ER = 1.3), but the 5 mM DMF in hypoxia results in nearly a complete collapse of the hypoxic dose-response curve to the same level as seen in air with DMF. It has been suggested previously that DMF sensitizes cells via electron affinic mechanisms. However, this appears not to be the case in this study, as shown by the fact that cells pretreated with DMF and then washed free of the drug remained equally radiosensitive as cells irradiated in the presence of the drug. This large enhancement of radiation sensitivity appears to be related to the drugs ability to deplete thiols; i.e., thiols appear to be a major factor responsible for radioresistance of hypoxic cells.