Lauren Peacock

A collagen-hydroxyapatite scaffold allows for binding and co-delivery of recombinant bone morphogenetic proteins and bisphosphonates.

An emerging paradigm in orthopedics is that a bone-healing outcome is the product of the anabolic (bone-forming) and catabolic (bone-resorbing) outcomes. Recently, surgical and tissue engineering strategies have emerged that combine recombinant human bone morphogenetic proteins (rhBMPs) and bisphosphonates (BPs) in order to maximize anabolism and minimize catabolism. Collagen-based scaffolds that are the current surgical standard can bind rhBMPs, but not BPs. We hypothesized that a biomimetic collagen-hydroxyapatite (CHA) scaffold would bind both agents and produce superior in vivo outcomes. Consistent with this concept, in vitro elution studies utilizing rhBMP-2 ELISA assays and scintillation counting of (14)C-radiolabeled zoledronic acid (ZA) confirmed delayed release of both agents from the CHA scaffold. Next, scaffolds were tested for their capacity to form ectopic bone after surgical implantation into the rat hind limb. Using CHA, a significant 6-fold increase in bone volume was seen in rhBMP-2/ZA groups compared to rhBMP-2 alone, confirming the ability of ZA to enhance rhBMP-2 bone formation. CHA scaffolds were found to be capable of generating mineralized tissue in the absence of rhBMP-2. This study has implications for future clinical treatments of critical bone defects. It demonstrates the relative advantages of co-delivering anabolic and anti-catabolic agents using a multicomponent scaffold system.

Intermittent PTH((1-34)) does not increase union rates in open rat femoral fractures and exhibits attenuated anabolic effects compared to closed fractures.

Intermittent Parathyroid Hormone (PTH)((1-34)) has an established place in osteoporosis treatment, but also shows promising results in models of bone repair. Previous studies have been dominated by closed fracture models, where union is certain. One of the major clinical needs for anabolic therapies is the treatment of open and high energy fractures at risk of non-union. In the present study we therefore compared PTH((1-34)) treatment in models of both open and closed fractures. 108 male Wistar rats were randomly assigned to undergo standardized closed fractures or open osteotomies with periosteal stripping. 27 rats in each group were treated s.c. with PTH((1-34)) at a dose of 50 mug/kg 5 days a week, the other 27 receiving saline. Specimens were harvested at 6 weeks for mechanical testing (n=17) or histological analysis (n=10). In closed fractures, union by any definition was 100% in both PTH((1-34)) and saline groups at 6 weeks. In open fractures, the union rate was significantly lower (p<0.05), regardless of treatment. In open fractures the mechanically defined union rate was 10/16 (63%) in saline and 11/17 (65%) in PTH((1-34)) treated fractures. By histology, the union rate was 3/9 (33%) with saline and 5/10 (50%) with PTH((1-34)). Radiological union was seen in 13/25 (52%) for saline and 15/26 (58%) with PTH((1-34)). Open fractures were associated with decreases in bone mineral content (BMC) and volumetric bone mineral density (vBMD) on quantitative computerized tomography (QCT) analysis compared to closed fractures. PTH((1-34)) treatment in both models led to significant increases in callus BMC and volume as well as trabecular bone volume/total volume (BV/TV), as assessed histologically (p<0.01). In closed fractures, PTH((1-34)) had a robust effect on callus size and strength, with a 60% increase in peak torque (p<0.05). In the open fractures that united and could be tested, PTH((1-34)) treatment also increased peak torque by 49% compared to saline (p<0.05). In conclusion, intermittent PTH((1-34)) produced significant increases in callus size and strength in closed fractures, but failed to increase the rate of union in an open fracture model. In the open fractures that did unite, a muted response to PTH was seen compared to closed fractures. Further research is required to determine if PTH((1-34)) is an appropriate anabolic treatment for open fractures.

Myogenic progenitors contribute to open but not closed fracture repair

BackgroundBone repair is dependent on the presence of osteocompetent progenitors that are able to differentiate and generate new bone. Muscle is found in close association with orthopaedic injury, however its capacity to make a cellular contribution to bone repair remains ambiguous. We hypothesized that myogenic cells of the MyoD-lineage are able to contribute to bone repair.MethodsWe employed a MyoD-Cre+:Z/AP+ conditional reporter mouse in which all cells of the MyoD-lineage are permanently labeled with a human alkaline phosphatase (hAP) reporter. We tracked the contribution of MyoD-lineage cells in mouse models of tibial bone healing.ResultsIn the absence of musculoskeletal trauma, MyoD-expressing cells are limited to skeletal muscle and the presence of reporter-positive cells in non-muscle tissues is negligible. In a closed tibial fracture model, there was no significant contribution of hAP+ cells to the healing callus. In contrast, open tibial fractures featuring periosteal stripping and muscle fenestration had up to 50% of hAP+ cells detected in the open fracture callus. At early stages of repair, many hAP+ cells exhibited a chondrocyte morphology, with lesser numbers of osteoblast-like hAP+ cells present at the later stages. Serial sections stained for hAP and type II and type I collagen showed that MyoD-lineage cells were surrounded by cartilaginous or bony matrix, suggestive of a functional role in the repair process. To exclude the prospect that osteoprogenitors spontaneously express MyoD during bone repair, we created a metaphyseal drill hole defect in the tibia. No hAP+ staining was observed in this model suggesting that the expression of MyoD is not a normal event for endogenous osteoprogenitors.ConclusionsThese data document for the first time that muscle cells can play a significant secondary role in bone repair and this knowledge may lead to important translational applications in orthopaedic surgery.Please see related article: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/9/136

A murine model of neurofibromatosis type 1 tibial pseudarthrosis featuring proliferative fibrous tissue and osteoclast-like cells

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is a common genetic condition caused by mutations in the NF1 gene. Patients often suffer from tissue‐specific lesions associated with local double‐inactivation of NF1. In this study, we generated a novel fracture model to investigate the mechanism underlying congenital pseudarthrosis of the tibia (CPT) associated with NF1. We used a Cre‐expressing adenovirus (AdCre) to inactivate Nf1 in vitro in cultured osteoprogenitors and osteoblasts, and in vivo in the fracture callus of Nf1flox/flox and Nf1flox/− mice. The effects of the presence of Nf1null cells were extensively examined. Cultured Nf1null‐committed osteoprogenitors from neonatal calvaria failed to differentiate and express mature osteoblastic markers, even with recombinant bone morphogenetic protein‐2 (rhBMP‐2) treatment. Similarly, Nf1null‐inducible osteoprogenitors obtained from Nf1  MyoDnull mouse muscle were also unresponsive to rhBMP‐2. In both closed and open fracture models in Nf1flox/flox and Nf1flox/− mice, local AdCre injection significantly impaired bone healing, with fracture union being <50% that of wild type controls. No significant difference was seen between Nf1flox/flox and Nf1flox/− mice. Histological analyses showed invasion of the Nf1null fractures by fibrous and highly proliferative tissue. Mean amounts of fibrous tissue were increased upward of 10‐fold in Nf1null fractures and bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) staining in closed fractures showed increased numbers of proliferating cells. In Nf1null fractures, tartrate‐resistant acid phosphatase–positive (TRAP+) cells were frequently observed within the fibrous tissue, not lining a bone surface. In summary, we report that local Nf1 deletion in a fracture callus is sufficient to impair bony union and recapitulate histological features of clinical CPT. Cell culture findings support the concept that Nf1 double inactivation impairs early osteoblastic differentiation. This model provides valuable insight into the pathobiology of the disease, and will be helpful for trialing therapeutic compounds.

Matrix metalloproteinase-driven endochondral fracture union proceeds independently of osteoclast activity.

As new insights into the complexities of endochondral fracture repair emerge, the temporal role of osteoclast activity remains ambiguous. With numerous antiresorptive agents available to treat bone disease, understanding their impact on bone repair is vital. Further, in light of recent work suggesting osteoclast activity may not be necessary during early endochondral fracture union, we hypothesize instead a pivotal role of matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) secreting cells in driving this process. Although the role of MMPs in fracture healing has been examined, no directly comparative experiments exist. We examined a number of antiresorptive treatments to either block osteoclast activity, including the potent bisphosphonates zoledronic acid (ZA) and clodronate (CLOD), which work via differing mechanisms, or antagonize osteoclastogenesis with recombinant OPG (HuOPG‐Fc), comparing these directly to an inhibitor of MMP activity (MMI270). Endochondral ossification to union occurred normally in all antiresorptive groups. In contrast, MMP inhibition greatly impaired endochondral union, significantly delaying cartilage callus removal. MMP inhibition also produced smaller, denser hard calluses. Hard callus remodeling was, as expected, delayed with ZA, CLOD, and OPG treatment at 4 and 6 weeks, resulting in larger, more mineralized calluses at 6 weeks. As a result of reduced hard callus turnover, bone formation was reduced with antiresorptive agents at these time points. These results confirm that the achievement of endochondral fracture union occurs independently of osteoclast activity. Alternatively, MMP secretion by invading cells is obligatory to endochondral union. This study provides new insight into cellular contributions to bone repair and may abate concerns regarding antiresorptive therapies impeding initial fracture union.

Endochondral fracture healing with external fixation in the Sost knockout mouse results in earlier fibrocartilage callus removal and increased bone volume fraction and strength

Sclerostin deficiency, via genetic knockout or anti-Sclerostin antibody treatment, has been shown to cause increased bone volume, density and strength of calluses following endochondral bone healing. However, there is limited data on the effect of Sclerostin deficiency on the formative early stage of fibrocartilage (non-bony tissue) formation and removal. In this study we extensively investigate the early fibrocartilage callus. Closed tibial fractures were performed on Sost(-/-) mice and age-matched wild type (C57Bl/6J) controls and assessed at multiple early time points (7, 10 and 14days), as well as at 28days post-fracture after bony union. External fixation was utilized, avoiding internal pinning and minimizing differences in stability stiffness, a variable that has confounded previous research in this area. Normal endochondral ossification progressed in wild type and Sost(-/-) mice with equivalent volumes of fibrocartilage formed at early day 7 and day 10 time points, and bony union in both genotypes by day 28. There were no significant differences in rate of bony union; however there were significant increases in fibrocartilage removal from the Sost(-/-) fracture calluses at day 14 suggesting earlier progression of endochondral healing. Earlier bone formation was seen in Sost(-/-) calluses over wild type with greater bone volume at day 10 (221%, p<0.01). The resultant Sost(-/-) united bony calluses at day 28 had increased bone volume fraction compared to wild type calluses (24%, p<0.05), and the strength of the fractured Sost(-/-) tibiae was greater than that that of wild type fractured tibiae. In summary, bony union was not altered by Sclerostin deficiency in externally-fixed closed tibial fractures, but fibrocartilage removal was enhanced and the resultant united bony calluses had increased bone fraction and increased strength.

Neuropeptide Y modulates fracture healing through Y1 receptor signaling

Neuropeptide Y acting via its Y1 receptor represents a powerful pathway in the control of bone mass. The global or osteoblast‐specific Y1 receptor deletion induces pronounced bone anabolic effects in mice. However, the contribution of Y1 receptor deletion in bone repair/healing remained to be clarified. Therefore, in this study we characterized the role of Y1 receptor deletion in fracture healing. Closed tibial fractures were generated in germline (Y1−/−) and osteoblastic‐specific Y1 receptor knockout mice. The progression of tibial repair monitored from 1‐ until 6‐weeks post‐fracture demonstrated that in Y1−/− mice there is a delay in fracture repair, as seen by a decrease in bone callus volume and callus strength. Moreover, the histological features included elevated avascular and cartilage area and consequently delayed cartilage removal, and hence impaired union. Interestingly, this delay in bone repair was not related directly to Y1 receptors expressed by mature osteoblasts. These findings suggest that the global absence of the Y1 receptor delays fracture healing, through impairing the early phases of fracture repair to achieve bony union. The data acquired on the role of Y1 receptor signaling disruption in bone regeneration is critical for the design of future therapeutic strategies.

Rapid cell culture and pre-clinical screening of a transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) inhibitor for orthopaedics

BackgroundTransforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) and bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) utilize parallel and related signaling pathways, however the interaction between these pathways in bone remains unclear. TGF-β inhibition has been previously reported to promote osteogenic differentiation in vitro, suggesting it may have a capacity to augment orthopaedic repair. We have explored this concept using an approach that represents a template for the testing of agents with prospective orthopaedic applications.MethodsThe effects of BMP-2, TGF-β1, and the TGF-β receptor (ALK-4/5/7) inhibitor SB431542 on osteogenic differentiation were tested in the MC3T3-E1 murine pre-osteoblast cell line. Outcome measures included alkaline phosphatase staining, matrix mineralization, osteogenic gene expression (Runx2, Alp, Ocn) and phosphorylation of SMAD transcription factors. Next we examined the effects of SB431542 in two orthopaedic animal models. The first was a marrow ablation model where reaming of the femur leads to new intramedullary bone formation. In a second model, 20 μg rhBMP-2 in a polymer carrier was surgically introduced to the hind limb musculature to produce ectopic bone nodules.ResultsBMP-2 and SB431542 increased the expression of osteogenic markers in vitro, while TGF-β1 decreased their expression. Both BMP-2 and SB431542 were found to stimulate pSMAD1 and we also observed a non-canonical repression of pSMAD2. In contrast, neither in vivo system was able to provide evidence of improved bone formation or repair with SB431542 treatment. In the marrow ablation model, systemic dosing with up to 10 mg/kg/day SB431542 did not significantly increase reaming-induced bone formation compared to vehicle only controls. In the ectopic bone model, local co-administration of 38 μg or 192 μg SB431542 did not increase bone formation.ConclusionsALK-4/5/7 inhibitors can promote osteogenic differentiation in vitro, but this may not readily translate to in vivo orthopaedic applications.

PTH(1-34) Treatment Increases Bisphosphonate Turnover in Fracture Repair in Rats.

Bisphosphonates (BP) are antiresorptive drugs with a high affinity for bone. Despite the therapeutic success in treating osteoporosis and metabolic bone diseases, chronic BP usage has been associated with reduced repair of microdamage and atypical femoral fracture (AFF). The latter has a poor prognosis, and although anabolic interventions such as teriparatide (PTH(1–34)) have been suggested as treatment options, there is a limited evidence base in support of their efficacy. Because PTH(1–34) acts to increase bone turnover, we hypothesized that it may be able to increase BP in turnover in the skeleton, which, in turn, may improve bone healing. To test this, we employed a mixture of fluorescent Alexa647‐labelled pamidronate (Pam) and radiolabeled 14C‐ZA (zoledronic acid). These traceable BPs were dosed to Wistar rats in models of normal growth and closed fracture repair. Rats were cotreated with saline or 25 μg/kg/d PTH(1–34), and the effects on BP liberation and bone healing were examined by X‐ray, micro‐CT, autoradiography, and fluorescent confocal microscopy. Consistent with increased BP remobilization with PTH(1–34), there was a significant decrease in fluorescence in both the long bones and in the fracture callus in treated animals compared with controls. This was further confirmed by autoradiography for 14C‐ZA. In this model of acute BP treatment, callus bone volume (BV) was significantly increased in fractured limbs, and although we noted significant decreases in callus‐bound BP with PTH(1–34), these were not sufficient to alter this BV. However, increased intracellular BP was noted in resorbing osteoclasts, confirming that, in principle, PTH(1–34) increases bone turnover as well as BP turnover.

Local Delivery of the Cationic Steroid Antibiotic CSA-90 Enables Osseous Union in a Rat Open Fracture Model of Staphylococcus aureus Infection

BACKGROUND Treatment of infected open fractures remains a major clinical challenge. In this study, we investigated the novel broad-spectrum antibiotic CSA-90 (cationic steroid antibiotic-90) as an antimicrobial agent. METHODS CSA-90 was screened in an osteoblast cell culture model for effects on differentiation and mineralization. Local delivery of CSA-90 was then tested alone and in combination with recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) in a mouse ectopic bone formation model (n=40 mice) and in a rat open fracture model inoculated with pathogenic Staphylococcus aureus (n=84 rats). RESULTS CSA-90 enhanced matrix mineralization in cultured osteoblasts and increased rhBMP-2-induced bone formation in vivo. All animals in which an open fracture had been inoculated with Staphylococcus aureus and not treated with local CSA-90, including those treated with rhBMP-2, had to be culled prior to the experimental end point (six weeks) because of localized osteolysis and deterioration of overall health, whereas CSA-90 prevented establishment of infection in all open fractures in which it was used (p≤0.012). Increased union rates were seen for the fractures treated with rhBMP-2 or with the combination of rhBMP-2 and CSA-90 compared with that observed for the fractures treated with CSA-90 alone (p=0.04). CONCLUSIONS CSA-90 can promote osteogenesis and be used for prevention of Staphylococcus aureus infection in preclinical models. CLINICAL RELEVANCE Local delivery of CSA-90 represents a novel strategy for prevention of infection and may have specific benefits in the context of orthopaedic injuries.