Stanley E. Stokowski

Alternating phase-shift mask inspection using multiple simultaneous illumunation techniques

This paper discusses the challenges to alternating phase shift mask defect inspection and new approaches for phase defect detection using multiple illumination methods in conjunction with defect detection algorithm modifications. Die-to-die inspection algorithms were developed for the KLA-Tencor 365UV-HR (APS algorithm) and TeraStar SLF27 (TeraPhase algorithm) inspection systems based upon the use of simultaneous transmitted and reflected light signals. The development of an AltPSM programmed test vehicle is described and defect sensitivity characterization results from programmed phase defect reticles are presented. A comparison of the two approaches used for the different inspection systems is discussed. A comparison of TeraPhase to transmitted light only results from a programmed phase defect test mask shows improved phase defect detection results.

Next-generation lithography mask inspection

KLA-Tencor and industry partners are collaborating on a project for developing early capabilities of inspecting NGL masks. The project, partially funded by NIST as part of the ATP program, is focusing on building a research tool that will provide experimental data for development of a production capable tool. Some of the key technical issues include contrast in transmission and reflection, defect sources and types, and maintaining mask cleanliness in the absence of pellicles. The masks need to be inspected at multiple process stages, starting with unpatterned substrates, and ending with the pattern inspection. System issues include defect sensitivity and inspection time, which need to be balanced.

Optical inspection of NGL masks

For the last five years KLA-Tencor and our joint venture partners have pursued a research program studying the ability of optical inspection tools to meet the inspection needs of possible NGL lithographies. The NGL technologies that we have studied include SCALPEL, PREVAIL, EUV lithography, and Step and Flash Imprint Lithography. We will discuss the sensitivity of the inspection tools and mask design factors that affect tool sensitivity. Most of the work has been directed towards EUV mask inspection and how to optimize the mask to facilitate inspection. Our partners have succeeded in making high contrast EUV masks ranging in contrast from 70% to 98%. Die to die and die to database inspection of EUV masks have been achieved with a sensitivity that is comparable to what can be achieved with conventional photomasks, approximately 80nm defect sensitivity. We have inspected SCALPEL masks successfully. We have found a limitation of optical inspection when applied to PREVAIL stencil masks. We have run inspections on SFIL masks in die to die, reflected light, in an effort to provide feedback to improve the masks. We have used a UV inspection system to inspect both unpatterned EUV substrates (no coatings) and blanks (with EUV multilayer coatings). These inspection results have proven useful in driving down the substrate and blank defect levels.

Optical inspection of EUV and SCALPEL reticles

Next Generation Lithography (NGL) reticle inspection poses some difficult problems. The masks dictate that reflection images, rather than the more usual transmission images, be used for inspection. The smaller linewidths and feature sizes of NGL will require the optical inspection images to have better resolution than has been needed for conventional masks. In this paper we present inspection images and inspection results for EUV and EPL programmed defect test reticles using both UV and DUV reticle inspection systems. Our emphasis has been on providing feedback to the mask manufacturing process to help optimize the inspectability of NGL masks, as well as determining whether the required sensitivity for the 100 nm and 70 nm nodes can be met with optical inspection. Simulated and actual images of NGL masks have proven useful in identifying the important factors in optimizing image contrast. We have found that image contrast varies markedly with inspection wavelength, and that the inspection wavelength must be considered in the design of NGL masks if optimum defect sensitivity is to be obtained. This research was sponsored in part by NIST-ATP and KLA-Tencor Cooperative Agreement #70NANB8H44024.

Inspection of alternating phase-shift masks through the use of phase contrast techniques

Alternating Phase Shift Masks (altPSMs) are an option for the production of critical layers at the 100 nm technology node and below. Successful implementation of altPSMs into a wafer manufacturing process depends upon the ability to successfully inspect, disposition and repair defects that occur during the mask manufacturing process. One technique previously described to improve phase defect contrast was the use of simultaneous transmitted and reflected light [1][2]. The previous technique provided for improved phase defect detection in altPSMs produced for the 130 nm node at a 248 nm lithographic wavelength. This work describes the results from a die-to-die inspection method that improves phase defect contrast in transmitted light for altPSMs produced for the 100 nm node at a 193 nm wavelength. The improved phase defect detection technique addresses the challenges of decreasing linewidth/pitch and reduced defect phase resulting from the decrease in lithographic wavelength relative to the inspection wavelength of light. The improved phase defect detection method also provides a method to determine whether a defect is a binary, phase bump or phase divot type of defect. Results are compared against the previous inspection methods. A test vehicle for gathering sensitivity performance data is described along with the results obtained from the inspection system.

Impact of EUV mask quality on optical inspection sensitivity

EUV masks are exposed at a wavelength of 13.4 nm, but patterned mask inspection will be in the wavelength range of 157 nm to 257 nm. This large mismatch in wavelength raises questions as to whether the defects that are found in inspection will be the defects that print in a EUV exposure tool. This paper addresses part of this question by considering how small certain nuisance defects must be in order to not limit the optical inspection tool’s sensitivity. That is, the tool must be capable of finding critical printing defects and must not find nonprinting defects. A nuisance defect is considered to be one that the inspection tool may be sensitive to, but will not print on a wafer. We have used a 3D Maxwell equation simulator to simulate the inspection images obtained for a variety of nuisance defects of different types and sizes. We have done these calculations assuming that the EUV lithography will be performed at mask dimensions of 200 nm lines and spaces with a 4X mask, so the features would print at 50 nm lines and spaces. We have determined the critical size of such nuisance defects to be 40nm or larger, depending on defect type. Nuisance defects larger than about 40 nm square may limit the inspection tool’s sensitivity to printing defects. The ITRS roadmap specification for patterned defects at the 50 nm node is 40 nm. Therefore, the limit in size for such nuisance defects is not more stringent than the limits that must be met to match the patterned defect size specification. This work should provide guidance in developing a EUV mask specification that ensures that inspection tools will be able to meet the needs of EUV lithography. This work has been sponsored in part by NIST-ATP Cooperative Agreement #70NANB8H44024.

Alternating Phase Shift Mask Inspection Through the Use of Phase Contrast Enhancement Techniques

Alternating Phase Shift Masks (altPSM’s) are an option for the production of critical layers at the 100 nm technology node and below produced at ArF lithographic wavelength. Successful implementation of altPSM’s depends upon the ability to successfully inspect, disposition and repair defects that occur during the manufacturing process. One technique previously described to improve phase defect contrast was the use of simultaneous transmitted and reflected light. The previously described technique provided for improved phase defect detection in altPSM’s produced for the 130 nm node at a 248 nm lithographic wavelength. This work describes the results from a die-to-die inspection method that improves phase defect contrast in transmitted light for altPSM’s produced for the 100 nm node at a 193 nm wavelength. The improved phase defect detection technique addresses the challenges of decreasing linewidth/pitch and reduced defect phase resulting from the decrease in lithographic wavelength relative to the inspection wavelength of light. The improved phase defect detection method also provides a method to determine whether a defect is a binary, phase bump or phase divot type of defect. Results are compared against the previous inspection methods. A test vehicle for gathering sensitivity performance data is described along with the results obtained from the inspection system.